Biases in economic decision making | AQA A-Level Economics
For Specification 7136
AQA A-Level Economics | Free Revision Notes
Estimated study time: 40 minutes
Behavioural economics helps explain why people's choices do not always match the predictions of traditional rational economic theory. This Biases in economic decision making A-Level Economics revision page focuses on three influences named by AQA: rules of thumb, anchoring and availability. These can simplify decisions, but they can also bias economic choices away from those predicted by a fully rational utility-maximising model. The lesson builds directly on bounded rationality and bounded self-control [Bounded rationality and bounded self-control] and prepares you for social norms, altruism and fairness [Social norms, altruism and fairness].
Learning Objectives 🎯
By the end of this revision page, you should be able to:
Explain how rules of thumb may be used when making economic decisions.
Define and explain anchoring.
Define and explain availability bias.
Distinguish rules of thumb, anchoring and availability bias.
Apply each bias to unfamiliar consumer decisions.
Analyse why these biases challenge the traditional assumption of rational utility-maximising behaviour.
Revision Notes 📚
Behavioural economics and biased decision making
Traditional economic theory assumes that individuals are rational economic decision makers who endeavour to maximise their utility.
Behavioural economists question whether people always behave in this way.
AQA specifically identifies the following biases within behavioural economic theory:
rules of thumb
anchoring
availability
social norms
Students should understand some of the reasons why an individual's economic decisions may be biased.
This lesson focuses on the first three. Social norms are developed separately in social norms, altruism and fairness [Social norms, altruism and fairness].
What is a bias in economic decision making?
A bias occurs when an individual's decision is systematically influenced in a particular direction rather than being based solely on the fully rational assessment assumed by traditional economic theory.
A bias may affect:
which information a person focuses on
how alternatives are compared
how much weight is given to particular information
which option is ultimately chosen
The basic behavioural chain is:
Economic choice
↓
Decision is influenced by a behavioural bias
↓
Alternatives are not assessed in the fully rational way assumed by traditional theory
↓
The choice may differ from the utility-maximising prediction
This does not mean every biased decision must produce a bad outcome. The important point is that the process of decision making is influenced.
Rules of thumb
A rule of thumb is a simple decision rule used to make a choice without carrying out a complete assessment of all the available alternatives.
Instead of considering every possible piece of information, a person uses a simpler guide.
For example, a consumer might follow a rule such as:
"I usually buy the cheapest option."
This rule makes the decision quicker and simpler.
However, the cheapest product may not necessarily provide the greatest utility to that particular consumer.
Why do people use rules of thumb?
Economic decisions can involve many alternatives and a large amount of information.
A rule of thumb reduces the complexity of the decision.
The process becomes:
Many alternatives
↓
Consumer uses a simple rule
↓
Fewer factors need to be considered
↓
Decision becomes easier
This links closely to bounded rationality and bounded self-control [Bounded rationality and bounded self-control].
If people's ability to process economic choices is limited, simple decision rules may help them make choices without attempting a complete utility-maximising calculation.
Rules of thumb can be useful
A rule of thumb is not automatically irrational.
It can make economic decisions:
quicker
simpler
easier to manage
Suppose a consumer regularly purchases a familiar product because they have been satisfied with it before.
Using this simple rule avoids reconsidering every alternative each time a purchase is made.
The difficulty is that the rule may cause the consumer to overlook information that would have changed their choice.
How rules of thumb may bias choices
Consider a consumer who always buys the lowest-priced option.
A lower price may be relevant to the decision, but a fully rational utility-maximising consumer would consider the alternatives in relation to their preferences and economic circumstances.
If the consumer automatically follows the rule:
"Always choose the cheapest"
they may ignore other relevant information.
The chain is:
Simple rule is adopted
↓
Consumer avoids a complete comparison
↓
Some relevant information may receive little or no attention
↓
Chosen option may differ from the fully rational utility-maximising choice
This shows how a useful shortcut can also produce biased behaviour.
Rules of thumb and rational choice
The difference can be summarised as follows:
Traditional rational model | Use of a rule of thumb |
Consumer evaluates relevant alternatives | Consumer follows a simplified decision rule |
Choice is assumed to maximise utility | Choice may be made without a complete comparison |
Relevant information is incorporated into the decision | Some information may be ignored |
Decision follows the rational model | Decision may be biased |
AQA mark schemes recognise rules of thumb as one of the biases relevant when questioning whether economic agents will always behave rationally to maximise utility.
What is anchoring?
Anchoring occurs when an individual's economic decision is influenced strongly by an initial or previously encountered piece of information.
That information acts as an anchor.
The consumer then makes later judgements in relation to that reference point rather than assessing the new situation independently.
AQA's specimen mark scheme specifically recognises that a previous price, or the first price at which a product was offered, can act as an anchor and affect later consumption decisions.
Anchoring and prices
Suppose a consumer first sees a product priced at:
$$£120$$
Later, the product is offered at:
$$£85$$
The original £120 may become the consumer's anchor.
The £85 price may consequently appear particularly attractive because the consumer compares it with £120.
The relevant behavioural chain is:
Initial price = £120
↓
£120 becomes an anchor
↓
Later price of £85 is judged relative to £120
↓
Consumer's perception of the later offer is influenced
↓
Purchasing decision may change
The key point is not whether £85 is objectively cheap.
The point is that the earlier figure influences the later judgement.
Previous prices as anchors
Anchoring can continue even when economic circumstances change.
Suppose a consumer has become accustomed to paying £50 for a particular type of product.
If market conditions change and similar products now usually cost £70, the consumer may continue using £50 as a reference point.
This can affect their willingness to buy at the new price.
AQA's specimen mark scheme uses this kind of logic when discussing spending choices and adjustments to different prices.
Anchoring can affect spending decisions
Suppose two consumers are shown the same final price but begin from different reference points.
Consumer A first sees:
$$£100$$
Consumer B first sees:
$$£70$$
Both are later offered the product for:
$$£75$$
Consumer A may interpret £75 as relatively attractive because it is below their £100 anchor.
Consumer B may interpret exactly the same £75 price as relatively unattractive because it is above their £70 anchor.
Therefore:
Same final price + different anchors → potentially different economic choices
This challenges the simple idea that decisions depend only upon current economic information.
Anchoring and rational economic behaviour
Traditional theory assumes consumers respond rationally to relevant economic incentives and endeavour to maximise utility.
Anchoring suggests that a consumer may give disproportionate importance to an earlier reference point.
The chain is:
Earlier information creates an anchor
↓
Later alternatives are judged relative to the anchor
↓
The anchor influences perceived attractiveness
↓
Choice may differ from one based only on the current alternatives
This provides a behavioural explanation of biased economic decision making.
What is availability bias?
Availability bias occurs when individuals give greater weight to information or examples that are particularly easy to recall when making a decision.
Information that comes readily to mind can therefore have a stronger effect on the decision than other relevant information.
The basic process is:
Some information is particularly easy to remember
↓
Consumer gives that information greater attention
↓
Other relevant information may receive less weight
↓
Economic judgement becomes biased
Availability is one of the biases specifically identified within the AQA specification.
Applying availability bias
Suppose a consumer is considering purchasing a particular type of product.
They can easily recall a recent example in which someone had a poor experience with such a product.
That memorable example may receive a large amount of weight in the consumer's decision.
The consumer may consequently avoid the product even though other information about the available choices points towards a different decision.
The behavioural issue is not necessarily that the remembered information is false.
The problem is that its availability in the consumer's mind affects how much weight it receives.
Easily remembered does not mean most important
Availability bias can occur because people do not necessarily give each piece of relevant information the weight that a fully rational assessment would require.
Information may be easy to recall because it is:
recent
particularly memorable
repeatedly encountered
A consumer may consequently treat it as especially important.
The chain is:
Information is easy to recall
↓
It becomes prominent in the decision
↓
Consumer gives it considerable weight
↓
Other information may be underweighted
↓
Choice may become biased
Availability and economic choices
Availability bias can influence choices about:
spending
consumption
saving
For example, if one recent experience is particularly easy to remember, it may influence a future spending decision more strongly than less memorable information.
The key exam skill is not producing a complicated example. It is explaining how readily available information alters the economic decision.
Rules of thumb, anchoring and availability compared
Bias | Main influence on decision making | Simple example |
Rule of thumb | Consumer follows a simple decision rule instead of making a complete assessment | "Always buy the cheapest option" |
Anchoring | An initial or previous reference point influences later judgements | A previous price affects whether the current price appears attractive |
Availability bias | Easily recalled information receives greater weight in the decision | A memorable recent experience strongly influences the next purchase |
The concepts can all lead to biased economic decisions, but the mechanisms are different.
How to distinguish the three in an exam
Ask what is driving the decision.
Is the consumer following a simple rule?
This suggests a rule of thumb.
Is the consumer relying heavily on an earlier number or reference point?
This suggests anchoring.
Is the consumer giving extra weight to something because it comes readily to mind?
This suggests availability bias.
This distinction is more useful than simply memorising three definitions.
Worked application 1: a rule of thumb
A consumer is comparing six products.
Instead of investigating all six, they automatically purchase the product with the lowest price.
Identify the bias
Rule of thumb
Explain the mechanism
The consumer uses a simple rule to reduce the complexity of the decision.
Explain the possible effect
Other information that might have influenced a utility-maximising choice may be overlooked.
Worked application 2: anchoring
A product was previously priced at £200 and is now priced at £140.
The consumer considers the new price a bargain mainly because they compare it with £200.
Identify the bias
Anchoring
Explain the mechanism
The previous £200 price acts as a reference point.
Explain the possible effect
The £140 offer appears more attractive because of the anchor, affecting the purchasing decision.
Worked application 3: availability bias
A consumer remembers one particularly negative recent experience when deciding whether to buy a similar product again.
Identify the bias
Availability bias
Explain the mechanism
The memorable experience is easy to recall and receives substantial weight in the decision.
Explain the possible effect
The consumer's choice may be influenced more by the easily remembered example than by a full assessment of the alternatives.
Biases and utility maximisation
Traditional economic theory assumes that individuals endeavour to maximise utility.
Biases challenge this model because consumers may not evaluate alternatives solely according to the fully rational process assumed by the theory.
For example:
Rule of thumb
Consumer simplifies the decision and may ignore relevant information.
Anchoring
Consumer gives excessive influence to a previous reference point.
Availability bias
Consumer gives more weight to readily recalled information.
In each case:
Decision-making process is biased → choice may differ from the fully rational utility-maximising prediction
Bias does not automatically mean the decision is harmful
A consumer influenced by a behavioural bias may still make a choice that turns out well.
Behavioural economics focuses on why the decision was made.
For example, a rule of thumb may sometimes lead to the same product the consumer would have chosen after a full assessment.
This does not mean the rule of thumb has disappeared.
It means the simplified decision happened to produce the same outcome.
Therefore, avoid writing:
"A biased choice is always a bad choice."
A more accurate statement is:
"A bias can cause the consumer's decision to differ from that predicted by the traditional rational-choice model."
Biases and bounded rationality
Biases connect closely with bounded rationality and bounded self-control [Bounded rationality and bounded self-control].
If individuals cannot make unlimited calculations or process every available alternative, they may rely on simpler ways of making decisions.
Rules of thumb provide one example.
Anchoring and availability also show that the way information influences decisions may differ from the fully rational model.
Together, these behavioural ideas strengthen the argument that consumer choices cannot always be understood simply by assuming perfect rationality.
Biases and imperfect information
Biases are also different from imperfect and asymmetric information [Imperfect and asymmetric information].
With imperfect information:
The consumer lacks relevant information.
With a behavioural bias:
The consumer's use or weighting of information affects the decision.
A consumer might therefore possess relevant information and still make a biased decision.
This distinction is important.
Simply supplying more information may not automatically remove all behavioural biases.
Biases and marketing
AQA's 2021 mark scheme recognises that behavioural actions can be used to suppress rationality, including through marketing, as well as to improve rationality.
This is important when analysing anchoring.
For example, the first price shown to a consumer can influence how a later price is judged.
The exact policy implications are developed later in:
choice architecture, framing and nudges [Choice architecture, framing and nudges]
and
behavioural economics and economic policy [Behavioural economics and economic policy].
For this lesson, focus on the decision-making bias itself.
Biases can affect market behaviour
If many consumers are affected by biases, their purchasing choices may influence the demand for goods and services.
For example:
Bias changes individual choices
↓
Many consumers alter spending decisions
↓
Market demand may be affected
The detailed demand model is introduced next in demand [Demand].
At this stage, the important point is that behavioural biases can influence real economic choices and therefore have consequences beyond a single individual.
Applying behavioural bias in an exam
Use a four-stage chain.
Step 1: Identify the bias
Name it precisely.
Step 2: Explain how it operates
State what is influencing the decision.
Step 3: Apply it to the context
Use the information from the scenario.
Step 4: Link it to rational behaviour
Explain why the resulting decision may differ from the fully rational utility-maximising prediction.
For anchoring, for example:
Previous price becomes an anchor → current price is judged relative to it → perceived attractiveness changes → spending decision changes
That is much stronger than simply writing "the consumer is anchored".
Key Words 🔑
Key word | Student-friendly definition | How it may be used in an exam |
Bias | An influence that systematically affects how an individual makes an economic decision. | Used when explaining why actual choices may depart from the traditional rational model. |
Rule of thumb | A simple decision rule used instead of carrying out a complete assessment of all alternatives. | Used to explain how consumers may simplify complicated choices. |
Anchoring | A bias in which an initial or previous reference point has a strong influence on a later decision. | Used when analysing how an earlier price or other reference point affects spending choices. |
Availability bias | A bias in which information that is easy to recall receives greater weight in a decision. | Used when analysing why memorable information can influence economic choices. |
Utility maximisation | The traditional assumption that individuals endeavour to obtain the greatest utility possible from their choices. | Used as the rational-consumer model against which behavioural biases can be compared. |
Common Mistakes ⚠️
Mistake: Treating every quick decision as irrational
Why this is incorrect: Rules of thumb can make decisions easier and may sometimes produce the same outcome as a more complete assessment.
How to improve: Explain how the rule may bias the decision rather than assuming it always produces a poor result.
Mistake: Confusing anchoring with availability bias
Why this is incorrect: Anchoring involves a reference point, while availability bias involves information receiving greater weight because it is easy to recall.
How to improve: Ask whether the scenario centres on an earlier anchor or on memorable information.
Mistake: Saying anchoring only occurs with prices
Why this is incorrect: Price is a clear AQA-supported application, but the key idea is the influence of an initial or previous reference point.
How to improve: Focus on the mechanism, while using previous prices as a strong exam example.
Mistake: Saying availability bias means information is unavailable
Why this is incorrect: The term means almost the opposite. The influential information is particularly available to memory.
How to improve: Remember: available in the mind = more likely to influence the judgement.
Mistake: Treating a rule of thumb as the same as bounded rationality
Why this is incorrect: Bounded rationality describes limitations on fully rational decision making. A rule of thumb is one way an individual may simplify a choice.
How to improve: Explain the link but keep the concepts distinct.
Mistake: Saying a biased decision must reduce utility
Why this is incorrect: Behavioural economics explains why the decision process differs from the traditional model. A biased choice does not have to produce a harmful outcome in every case.
How to improve: Use the more precise conclusion that the choice may differ from the fully rational utility-maximising prediction.
Mistake: Listing biases without explaining how they change choices
Why this is incorrect: AQA expects students to understand reasons why economic decisions may be biased, not simply recall terminology.
How to improve: Always build a chain from the bias to the resulting change in economic behaviour.
Exam-Style Questions ✍️
Question 1
Define a rule of thumb in the context of economic decision making. [2 marks]
Question 2
Define anchoring. [2 marks]
Question 3
Define availability bias. [2 marks]
Question 4
A consumer always purchases the lowest-priced product without comparing the other characteristics of the alternatives.
Explain how a rule of thumb may be influencing the consumer's choice. [4 marks]
Question 5
A product was initially offered to a consumer for £150. The price is later reduced to £100 and the consumer immediately regards it as very good value.
Explain how anchoring may influence this decision. [6 marks]
Question 6
A consumer is deciding whether to purchase a product. A recent memorable negative experience with a similar product is the first information that comes to mind.
Explain how availability bias may affect the consumer's decision. [6 marks]
Question 7
Two consumers are both offered the same product for £80.
Consumer A previously saw the product priced at £120.
Consumer B previously saw it priced at £70.
Analyse why anchoring may cause the two consumers to respond differently to the £80 price. [8 marks]
Question 8
Explain how rules of thumb, anchoring and availability bias can cause consumer behaviour to differ from the predictions of traditional economic theory. [15 marks]
Question 9
Assess the view that behavioural biases mean consumers cannot be regarded as rational economic decision makers. [25 marks]
Answers and mark scheme
Question 1
Award up to 2 marks for recognising that:
a rule of thumb is a simple decision rule
it is used instead of a complete assessment of all alternatives
Indicative answer: A rule of thumb is a simple rule used to make an economic choice without carrying out a complete comparison of every available alternative.
Question 2
Award up to 2 marks for recognising that:
an initial or previous reference point influences a later decision
later alternatives are judged in relation to that anchor
Indicative answer: Anchoring occurs when an initial or previous piece of information acts as a reference point and strongly influences a later economic judgement.
Question 3
Award up to 2 marks for recognising that:
information is especially easy to recall
this information receives greater weight in the decision
Indicative answer: Availability bias occurs when information that is particularly easy to recall has a disproportionately strong influence on an economic decision.
Question 4
Award up to 4 marks.
Indicative content:
the consumer follows the simple rule "buy the cheapest"
this reduces the complexity of the decision
they do not carry out a complete comparison of the alternatives
relevant information other than price may be ignored
the final choice may therefore differ from the fully rational utility-maximising choice
Question 5
Award up to 6 marks.
Indicative content:
the original £150 price acts as an anchor
the consumer uses £150 as a reference point
the new £100 price is judged relative to this reference
£100 therefore appears substantially cheaper
this affects the perceived attractiveness of the product
the consumer may consequently be more likely to purchase it
Higher marks require a clear link from the anchor to the spending decision.
Question 6
Award up to 6 marks.
Indicative content:
the negative experience is particularly easy to remember
it therefore becomes prominent when the consumer makes the decision
the consumer gives this information considerable weight
other relevant information about the current product may receive less weight
their assessment of the purchase is consequently biased
the consumer may avoid the product even if a complete assessment would have produced another choice
Question 7
Award up to 8 marks for developed analysis.
Indicative chain:
Consumer A
$$£120 \text{ anchor} \rightarrow £80 \text{ appears relatively cheap}$$
This may increase the perceived attractiveness of the offer.
Consumer B
$$£70 \text{ anchor} \rightarrow £80 \text{ appears relatively expensive}$$
This may reduce the perceived attractiveness of the same offer.
Therefore, the two consumers face the same current price but may make different choices because their earlier reference points differ.
This illustrates how anchoring can cause decisions to depend on previous information rather than solely on the current economic choice.
Question 8
Indicative content for a 15-mark response:
Traditional economic theory assumes that individuals are rational economic decision makers who endeavour to maximise their utility.
Behavioural economics identifies several reasons why actual decisions may be biased.
A rule of thumb allows a consumer to simplify a complex decision by following a basic rule rather than assessing every alternative fully. This can reduce the information considered and may lead to a different choice from the fully rational utility-maximising outcome.
Anchoring occurs when an initial or previous reference point influences a later judgement. For example, AQA's specimen material recognises that a previous price can act as an anchor. A consumer may therefore judge a current price in relation to an earlier price rather than assessing it independently.
Availability bias occurs when easily recalled information receives greater weight. A memorable recent experience may therefore influence a consumer's economic judgement more strongly than other relevant information.
These biases challenge the traditional model because consumer decisions can depend on simplified rules, reference points and the prominence of particular information rather than a complete rational assessment of the alternatives.
For a high-quality response:
explain the traditional rational-consumer assumption
define all three biases accurately
distinguish clearly between the three mechanisms
apply each to an economic decision
develop the effect on the consumer's choice
connect each bias explicitly to possible departures from utility maximisation
Question 9
Indicative content for a 25-mark response:
Arguments supporting the view may include:
rules of thumb show that consumers may simplify decisions rather than evaluate every alternative
anchoring means previous reference points can influence current choices
availability bias means memorable information may receive disproportionate weight
bounded rationality can reinforce the use of simplified decision-making processes
actual choices may therefore differ from those predicted by a model of complete rational utility maximisation
AQA mark schemes recognise biases such as rules of thumb, anchoring and availability as relevant when discussing whether economic agents will always act rationally.
Arguments challenging the view may include:
a rule of thumb can sometimes produce a sensible outcome
the presence of behavioural biases does not mean every economic decision is irrational
consumers may still respond to economic incentives and make reasoned choices in many situations
behavioural economics questions the assumption of universal rationality rather than proving that rational behaviour never occurs
Judgement:
Behavioural biases provide strong reasons to reject the claim that consumers always make fully rational utility-maximising decisions. However, their existence does not establish that consumers are incapable of rational economic decision making. A more defensible conclusion is that rationality is a useful simplifying assumption whose ability to explain actual behaviour varies according to the circumstances and the influence of behavioural biases.
For the strongest response, focus carefully on any absolute wording such as always or cannot, and compare the traditional and behavioural explanations throughout rather than treating them as unrelated theories.

Comments