Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination | AQA A-Level Economics
For Specification 7136
AQA A-Level Economics | Free Revision Notes
Estimated study time: 50 to 60 minutes
Price discrimination becomes much easier to analyse when the different consumer groups are shown as separate markets. In this Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination A-Level Economics revision page, you will construct demand and marginal revenue diagrams for different market segments, use $MC=MR$ to determine output, and identify the different prices charged. You will then analyse how discriminatory pricing can change total output, producer revenue and profit compared with a single-price monopoly. AQA explicitly expects diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination.
Learning Objectives 🎯
By the end of this revision page, you should be able to:
Construct diagrams showing price discrimination between separate markets.
Use $MC=MR$ to determine the profit-maximising output in each market.
Determine the price charged to each consumer group from its AR curve.
Explain the relationship between price elasticity of demand and the discriminatory price.
Analyse how price discrimination may change total output and producer revenue.
Analyse why successful price discrimination may increase a firm's profit compared with charging a single price.
Revision Notes 📚
Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination A-Level Economics revision
AQA requires students to understand the conditions, advantages and disadvantages of price discrimination and explicitly states that diagrammatic analysis is expected. Students must also be able to assess its impact on producers and consumers.
The basic model combines ideas from:
price discrimination [Price discrimination]
price elasticity of demand [Price elasticity of demand]
revenue curves [Revenue curves]
profit maximisation [Profit maximisation]
monopoly [Monopoly].
The central idea is simple:
different groups have different demand conditions
↓
the firm separates the groups
↓
each market has its own AR and MR curves
↓
the firm determines output using marginal analysis
↓
different prices can be charged
Revisiting the conditions for price discrimination
Before a firm can use the model, the conditions studied in price discrimination [Price discrimination] must be met.
The firm needs:
sufficient monopoly power
identifiable and separable markets
different demand conditions between the markets
the ability to prevent or restrict resale between the markets.
AQA mark schemes identify monopoly power, market segmentation, prevention of cross-selling and differences in price elasticity of demand as important to the analysis.
The diagram then shows what the firm may do once those conditions exist.
Why separate diagrams are needed
Suppose a firm sells essentially the same service to two different groups.
Market A
Consumers have relatively price-inelastic demand.
Market B
Consumers have relatively price-elastic demand.
If the markets can be kept separate, the firm does not need to charge both groups the same price.
Instead, each market can be represented by its own:
average revenue curve
marginal revenue curve.
The firm's pricing decision can therefore respond to the different demand conditions.
The two-market model
A standard way to illustrate price discrimination is to construct separate diagrams for:
Market A, where demand is relatively inelastic
Market B, where demand is relatively elastic.
Each diagram contains:
$$AR=D$$
and:
$$MR$$
The MR curve lies below the AR curve because each market has a downward-sloping demand curve.
The key relationship
The firm allocates output so that marginal revenue from the final unit sold in each market is consistent with the marginal cost of producing that output.
In a simplified diagram with a common constant marginal cost:
$$MR_A=MC$$
and:
$$MR_B=MC$$
Therefore:
$$MR_A=MR_B=MC$$
The firm then reads the price in each market from the relevant AR curve.
Constructing Market A: relatively inelastic demand
Step 1: Draw the axes
Vertical axis:
Costs and revenue
Horizontal axis:
Output
Step 2: Draw the AR curve
Draw a downward-sloping AR curve.
Because demand in Market A is relatively inelastic, draw it relatively steeply.
Label:
$$AR_A=D_A$$
Step 3: Draw MR
Draw:
$$MR_A$$
below the AR curve.
Step 4: Draw MC
For a simplified two-market diagram, draw a horizontal marginal cost curve.
Label:
$$MC$$
Step 5: Find profit-maximising output
Locate:
$$MR_A=MC$$
Drop vertically to the output axis.
Label the output:
$$Q_A$$
Step 6: Find price
Move vertically upwards from $Q_A$ to:
$$AR_A$$
Read the corresponding price:
$$P_A$$
This gives the profit-maximising price and output for Market A.
Constructing Market B: relatively elastic demand
Repeat the process for Market B.
Step 1: Draw AR
Draw a flatter downward-sloping demand curve:
$$AR_B=D_B$$
The flatter curve represents relatively more elastic demand.
Step 2: Draw MR
Draw:
$$MR_B$$
below AR.
Step 3: Draw the same MC
If the simplified model assumes the marginal cost of supplying each market is the same, draw MC at the same level as in Market A.
Step 4: Find output
Locate:
$$MR_B=MC$$
and identify:
$$Q_B$$
Step 5: Find price
Move vertically from $Q_B$ to $AR_B$.
This gives:
$$P_B$$
You now have a pair of diagrams showing price discrimination.
Comparing the two prices
The most important relationship is:
less elastic market → higher price
more elastic market → lower price
Therefore, in the standard example:
$$P_A>P_B$$
where Market A has the less elastic demand.
Why?
Consumers in Market A are less responsive to price changes.
A higher price causes a proportionately smaller reduction in quantity demanded.
The firm can therefore extract more revenue from these consumers through a relatively high price.
Consumers in Market B are more price sensitive.
The firm charges them a lower price to encourage purchases.
Analytical chain
Market A has less elastic demand
↓
consumers respond relatively little to a higher price
↓
firm can charge a higher profit-maximising price
while:
Market B has more elastic demand
↓
consumers respond strongly to price
↓
firm charges a lower price
This is the heart of the diagrammatic model.
Do not confuse elasticity with the slope alone
In simplified examination diagrams, the relatively inelastic market is often represented by a steeper demand curve and the relatively elastic market by a flatter curve.
However, your written analysis should refer explicitly to price elasticity of demand, not merely the visual steepness of the line.
Use:
"Demand in Market A is relatively less price elastic than demand in Market B."
rather than simply:
"Market A has a steeper line."
Determining output in each market
The quantity supplied in each market is determined through marginal analysis.
For Market A:
$$MR_A=MC$$
gives:
$$Q_A$$
For Market B:
$$MR_B=MC$$
gives:
$$Q_B$$
Total output is then:
$$Q_T=Q_A+Q_B$$
Example
Suppose:
$$Q_A=400$$
and:
$$Q_B=700$$
Then:
$$Q_T=400+700$$
$$Q_T=1,100$$
The firm produces 1,100 units in total and allocates them between the two markets.
Do not assume the elastic market must always have the larger quantity
The elasticity of demand helps explain the different prices, but the actual amount sold in each market also depends on:
the size of that market
the position of its demand curve
marginal revenue
marginal cost.
Therefore, do not automatically write:
"The elastic market must always have the highest output."
Instead, find the output from the relevant diagram.
The firm's basic allocation rule
The simplified logic is:
$$MR_A=MR_B=MC$$
Why?
Suppose:
$$MR_A>MR_B$$
for the marginal units currently being sold.
The firm could potentially increase total profit by reallocating sales towards Market A, where an additional unit generates greater marginal revenue.
Output allocation continues until the relevant marginal revenues are brought into line with marginal cost.
This applies the same marginal principle used throughout the theory of the firm.
A numerical example
Suppose a firm has separated consumers into two markets.
At the profit-maximising outputs:
Market A
$$MR_A=£10$$
$$MC=£10$$
$$Q_A=300$$
and the AR curve gives:
$$P_A=£24$$
Market B
$$MR_B=£10$$
$$MC=£10$$
$$Q_B=500$$
and the AR curve gives:
$$P_B=£15$$
The firm therefore charges:
$$£24$$
in Market A and:
$$£15$$
in Market B.
Total output is:
$$300+500=800$$
units.
The higher price in Market A is consistent with its relatively less elastic demand.
Producer revenue under price discrimination
Total revenue is:
$$TR=P\times Q$$
Under price discrimination, revenue is calculated separately for each market.
For Market A:
$$TR_A=P_A\times Q_A$$
For Market B:
$$TR_B=P_B\times Q_B$$
Total producer revenue is:
$$TR_T=TR_A+TR_B$$
Using the previous example
Market A:
$$TR_A=£24\times300$$
$$TR_A=£7,200$$
Market B:
$$TR_B=£15\times500$$
$$TR_B=£7,500$$
Total revenue:
$$TR_T=£7,200+£7,500$$
$$TR_T=£14,700$$
The firm's total revenue across the two markets is therefore:
$$£14,700$$
Showing revenue on the diagrams
Revenue in each market can be shown as a rectangle.
For Market A:
height = $P_A$
width = $Q_A$.
Therefore:
$$TR_A=P_AQ_A$$
For Market B:
height = $P_B$
width = $Q_B$.
Therefore:
$$TR_B=P_BQ_B$$
The total revenue earned by the firm is the sum of the two rectangles.
Comparing with a single-price monopolist
To analyse the effect of price discrimination properly, you need a comparison.
The most appropriate comparison is normally:
price-discriminating firm
versus:
the same firm charging a single monopoly price.
AQA mark schemes specifically recognise comparison with a non-discriminating monopolist when analysing price discrimination.
Do not automatically compare price discrimination with perfect competition.
The single-price outcome
Without price discrimination, the firm cannot charge separate groups different prices for essentially the same product.
It must choose one price.
Call this:
$$P_S$$
with total quantity:
$$Q_S$$
Producer revenue is:
$$TR_S=P_SQ_S$$
With discrimination, it instead earns:
$$TR_D=P_AQ_A+P_BQ_B$$
Successful price discrimination may produce:
$$TR_D>TR_S$$
AQA's specimen mark scheme explicitly recognises that price discrimination can increase producer revenue and profit compared with a single price.
Worked comparison of revenue
Suppose a firm can charge one price of £20 and sell 600 units.
Single price
$$TR_S=£20\times600$$
$$TR_S=£12,000$$
Now suppose price discrimination allows the firm to separate consumers into two groups.
Market A
$$P_A=£30$$
$$Q_A=300$$
Revenue:
$$TR_A=£30\times300=£9,000$$
Market B
$$P_B=£15$$
$$Q_B=400$$
Revenue:
$$TR_B=£15\times400=£6,000$$
Total discriminating revenue:
$$TR_D=£9,000+£6,000$$
$$TR_D=£15,000$$
Change in revenue:
$$£15,000-£12,000=£3,000$$
Producer revenue has increased by:
$$£3,000$$
Why can revenue rise?
A single-price firm faces a compromise.
If it charges a high price:
it extracts more revenue per unit from consumers willing to pay more
but it may exclude more price-sensitive consumers.
If it charges a low price:
it attracts price-sensitive consumers
but also charges the low price to consumers who were willing to pay more.
Price discrimination allows the firm to do both:
higher price to less elastic group
lower price to more elastic group
↓
more consumer willingness to pay can be converted into producer revenue
This is why price discrimination may increase total revenue.
Consumer surplus and producer revenue
The specimen AQA mark scheme recognises that price discrimination may allow a producer to convert some consumer surplus into producer surplus.
Suppose a consumer would have been willing to pay:
$$£30$$
but under single pricing pays:
$$£20$$
Their consumer surplus is:
$$£30-£20=£10$$
If discriminatory pricing raises their price to £27:
$$£30-£27=£3$$
Their consumer surplus has fallen by £7.
Part of the value previously retained by the consumer has effectively been captured by the producer.
The detailed welfare consequences are developed later in consumer and producer surplus [Consumer and producer surplus] and evaluating price discrimination [Evaluating price discrimination].
Price discrimination and total output
Price discrimination can also change total output.
AQA's June 2024 mark scheme recognises that price discrimination can result in higher levels of output than otherwise, increasing market access.
Why?
A single-price monopolist may set a price that excludes relatively price-sensitive consumers.
Price discrimination allows a lower price to be offered to that market while maintaining a higher price elsewhere.
Therefore:
lower price in elastic market
↓
additional consumers purchase
↓
output in that market rises
↓
total firm output may increase
Numerical example of increased output
Suppose a single-price monopolist sells:
$$Q_S=800$$
units.
With discrimination:
$$Q_A=350$$
and:
$$Q_B=600$$
Total discriminatory output is:
$$Q_D=350+600$$
$$Q_D=950$$
Therefore:
$$Q_D-Q_S=950-800$$
$$=150$$
Total output is 150 units higher.
This is one reason price discrimination can sometimes increase access to a product.
But higher total output is not a mechanical rule
Be careful with wording.
AQA recognises higher output as a possible benefit, but a diagram or context must support the conclusion.
Do not simply state:
"Price discrimination always increases output."
A better statement is:
"Price discrimination may increase total output because a lower price can be charged to consumers who would not purchase at the single monopoly price."
The higher-price market
For consumers in the relatively less elastic market:
$$P_A>P_S$$
may occur.
The firm can extract more revenue from these consumers because their demand is less responsive to price.
The likely chain is:
less elastic demand
↓
higher discriminatory price
↓
lower consumer surplus for those consumers
↓
greater producer revenue from that market
This becomes important when you evaluate the distributional effects in evaluating price discrimination [Evaluating price discrimination].
The lower-price market
For consumers in the relatively more elastic market:
$$P_B<P_S$$
may occur.
A lower price can encourage consumers who would otherwise not purchase to enter the market.
The chain is:
more elastic demand
↓
lower discriminatory price
↓
greater quantity purchased in that segment
↓
additional producer revenue
↓
possible increase in total output
This is why price discrimination does not necessarily mean every consumer pays more.
Revenue and profit are not the same thing
A common mistake is to assume:
higher revenue = higher profit
Profit is:
$$\text{Profit}=TR-TC$$
Therefore, an increase in revenue increases profit only if it is not offset by an equal or larger increase in total costs.
For example:
Before discrimination
$$TR=£100,000$$
$$TC=£70,000$$
Therefore:
$$\text{Profit}=£30,000$$
After discrimination
$$TR=£125,000$$
but:
$$TC=£80,000$$
Therefore:
$$\text{Profit}=£45,000$$
Profit has increased by:
$$£45,000-£30,000=£15,000$$
not by £25,000.
Why costs might change
If price discrimination increases total output, total production costs may also increase.
There may also be costs associated with:
identifying market segments
administering different pricing systems.
The June 2024 mark scheme recognises administration costs associated with segmenting markets as relevant to evaluating price discrimination.
Therefore:
price discrimination → greater revenue
does not by itself tell you the precise increase in profit.
You must consider costs.
Calculating profit under price discrimination
If average cost is known, total profit can be calculated.
Suppose:
$$Q_A=300$$
$$P_A=£30$$
and:
$$Q_B=500$$
$$P_B=£18$$
Total revenue is:
$$TR=(£30\times300)+(£18\times500)$$
$$TR=£9,000+£9,000$$
$$TR=£18,000$$
Total output is:
$$Q_T=800$$
Suppose average cost across total production is:
$$AC=£12$$
Total cost is:
$$TC=£12\times800$$
$$TC=£9,600$$
Profit is:
$$\text{Profit}=£18,000-£9,600$$
$$\text{Profit}=£8,400$$
Comparing profit with single pricing
Suppose the same firm previously used a single price and earned:
$$TR_S=£15,000$$
with:
$$TC_S=£9,000$$
Profit under single pricing was:
$$£15,000-£9,000=£6,000$$
Profit under discrimination is:
$$£8,400$$
Therefore:
$$\Delta\text{Profit}=£8,400-£6,000$$
$$\Delta\text{Profit}=£2,400$$
Price discrimination has increased producer profit by £2,400 in this example.
Profit rectangles in separate-market diagrams
If each market diagram includes an appropriate average cost curve, abnormal profit in each segment can be illustrated by the familiar rectangle:
$$\text{Profit}=(P-AC)\times Q$$
However, take care.
Where one firm serves both markets, its costs ultimately relate to its total production, so constructing separate market cost curves can introduce unnecessary assumptions.
For AQA analysis, separate AR and MR diagrams combined with accurate revenue and total-profit calculations can often make the economic mechanism much clearer.
The priority is to produce an internally consistent diagram and explain it.
A three-diagram approach
A more developed price-discrimination illustration can use three linked diagrams:
Diagram 1: Market A
Relatively inelastic demand:
$AR_A$
$MR_A$
higher price $P_A$
output $Q_A$.
Diagram 2: Market B
Relatively elastic demand:
$AR_B$
$MR_B$
lower price $P_B$
output $Q_B$.
Diagram 3: Total market or firm
Shows the firm's overall cost conditions and total output.
This can make the link between the two markets and the firm's total production clearer.
However, the precise diagram should always match the explanation being given. AQA rewards relevant diagrams that are accurately constructed and actually used in the analysis.
A simpler two-diagram method is often enough
If the question is asking how different demand elasticities lead to different prices, two clear market diagrams may be sufficient:
Market A: less elastic
$$MR_A=MC\rightarrow Q_A\rightarrow AR_A\rightarrow P_A$$
Market B: more elastic
$$MR_B=MC\rightarrow Q_B\rightarrow AR_B\rightarrow P_B$$
Then explain:
$$P_A>P_B$$
because demand in Market A is less price elastic.
Accuracy beats unnecessary complexity.
Diagram labels checklist
For a strong price-discrimination diagram, make sure you label:
Costs and revenue on the vertical axis
Output on the horizontal axis
$AR_A$ and $MR_A$ in Market A
$AR_B$ and $MR_B$ in Market B
$MC$
$Q_A$
$Q_B$
$P_A$
$P_B$.
Your written explanation should then refer directly to those labels.
The full diagrammatic chain
A strong answer can follow this structure.
Market A
Demand is relatively inelastic.
$$MR_A=MC$$
determines:
$$Q_A$$
Price is read from:
$$AR_A$$
giving:
$$P_A$$
Market B
Demand is relatively elastic.
$$MR_B=MC$$
determines:
$$Q_B$$
Price is read from:
$$AR_B$$
giving:
$$P_B$$
Comparison
Because Market A has relatively less elastic demand:
$$P_A>P_B$$
Producer revenue
$$TR=P_AQ_A+P_BQ_B$$
Producer profit
$$\text{Profit}=TR-TC$$
If the extra revenue generated exceeds any additional costs:
profit rises compared with single pricing.
Worked two-market example
Suppose a cinema can distinguish two groups of customers.
Market A
Demand is relatively inelastic.
The diagram indicates:
$$Q_A=200$$
$$P_A=£15$$
Revenue:
$$TR_A=£15\times200$$
$$TR_A=£3,000$$
Market B
Demand is relatively elastic.
The diagram indicates:
$$Q_B=400$$
$$P_B=£8$$
Revenue:
$$TR_B=£8\times400$$
$$TR_B=£3,200$$
Total output
$$Q_T=200+400$$
$$Q_T=600$$
Total revenue
$$TR_T=£3,000+£3,200$$
$$TR_T=£6,200$$
If total costs are £3,800:
$$\text{Profit}=£6,200-£3,800$$
$$\text{Profit}=£2,400$$
The example demonstrates how different prices can be combined to calculate the firm's overall revenue and profit.
Comparing the example with uniform pricing
Suppose without price discrimination the cinema charges:
$$P_S=£10$$
and sells:
$$Q_S=500$$
Revenue is:
$$TR_S=£10\times500$$
$$TR_S=£5,000$$
Suppose total cost at 500 customers is £3,500.
Profit is:
$$£5,000-£3,500=£1,500$$
Under price discrimination:
$$TR_D=£6,200$$
and:
$$\text{Profit}_D=£2,400$$
Therefore:
Change in output
$$600-500=100$$
Total output rises by 100 admissions.
Change in revenue
$$£6,200-£5,000=£1,200$$
Revenue rises by £1,200.
Change in profit
$$£2,400-£1,500=£900$$
Profit rises by £900.
This shows why you must distinguish revenue from profit.
Price discrimination and capacity utilisation
Diagrammatic analysis can also support the capacity-utilisation argument introduced in price discrimination [Price discrimination].
Suppose an off-peak market has relatively elastic demand.
A lower discriminatory price increases quantity demanded during the quieter period.
Therefore:
lower off-peak price
↓
higher off-peak quantity demanded
↓
more existing capacity used
↓
better capacity utilisation
AQA's specimen mark scheme identifies peak and off-peak rail fares and improved capacity utilisation as relevant consequences of discriminatory pricing.
Price discrimination and economies of scale
If discriminatory pricing raises total output:
$$Q_D>Q_S$$
the firm may be able to spread fixed costs over more units.
This could contribute to lower average costs.
AQA's specimen mark scheme recognises that increased sales through price discrimination may help generate economies of scale.
The possible chain is:
lower price offered to elastic segment
↓
additional demand
↓
greater total output
↓
fixed costs spread more widely
↓
average costs may fall
↓
profit may increase further
This outcome is possible rather than automatic.
Using diagrams in an exam
A diagram should form part of your analysis.
Do not:
draw two diagrams
never mention them again.
Instead write something like:
"In Market A, the firm produces $Q_A$ where $MR_A=MC$. The price $P_A$ is then determined from $AR_A$. Because demand in Market A is less price elastic than in Market B, the discriminatory price $P_A$ is higher than $P_B$."
This turns the diagram into economic analysis.
AQA's June 2024 report emphasises that diagrams contribute much more effectively when students explain and integrate them into their chains of reasoning rather than leaving them unused.
What the diagram does not prove
A diagram can show that one group pays more than another.
It does not automatically prove that:
every consumer is worse off
total output must rise
profit rises by exactly the increase in revenue
price discrimination is economically desirable.
These are separate analytical or evaluative questions.
The next lesson, evaluating price discrimination [Evaluating price discrimination], considers these consequences explicitly.
Higher and lower prices must both be considered
One of the most important lessons from AQA examiner reports is that price discrimination has different effects on different consumers.
The June 2024 report noted that weaker responses often considered only consumers paying higher prices and overlooked those receiving lower prices. Stronger responses used diagrams and context to explain the differing effects across consumer groups.
Your diagram should make this visible:
$$P_A>P_S>P_B$$
may occur in a typical comparison.
This means:
Market A consumers pay more than under single pricing
Market B consumers pay less
total output may increase.
Do not compare every discriminatory price with zero or marginal cost
The relevant comparison for this topic is normally with the single-price monopoly outcome.
For example:
$$P_A>P_S$$
while:
$$P_B<P_S$$
This demonstrates redistribution between consumer groups much more effectively than simply stating that the high-price group is being charged "a lot".
Diagrammatic analysis and welfare
AQA also expects students later in the specification to apply consumer and producer surplus to welfare issues including price discrimination.
However, detailed surplus and welfare diagrams belong primarily to:
consumer and producer surplus [Consumer and producer surplus]
monopoly, welfare and surplus [Monopoly, welfare and surplus].
For Lesson 63, the main focus is:
different demand conditions → different prices and outputs → changes in producer revenue and profit.
A complete exam method
When faced with a price-discrimination diagram question:
1. Identify the markets
Explain how consumers have been separated.
2. Compare elasticity
Identify which market has:
relatively less elastic demand
relatively more elastic demand.
3. Draw AR and MR
Draw separate:
$$AR=D$$
and:
$$MR$$
curves for each market.
4. Apply marginal analysis
Find the relevant output in each market using:
$$MR=MC$$
5. Find each price
Move from each output vertically to its AR curve.
6. Compare prices
Explain why:
less elastic demand → higher price
7. Calculate revenue if data are given
$$TR=P\times Q$$
for each market, then add them.
8. Calculate profit if costs are given
$$\text{Profit}=TR-TC$$
9. Compare with single pricing
Analyse changes in:
price
total output
revenue
profit.
That covers the core diagrammatic skills required for this lesson.
Key Words 🔑
Key word | Student-friendly definition | How it may be used in an exam |
Market segment | A separately identifiable group of consumers to whom a firm can charge a particular price. | Construct separate demand and MR curves for different groups. |
Discriminatory price | A price charged to one identifiable consumer group as part of a price-discrimination strategy. | Compare $P_A$ and $P_B$ between markets with different elasticities. |
Marginal revenue | The addition to total revenue from selling an extra unit of output. | Use $MR=MC$ to determine the output allocated to each market. |
Producer revenue | The total income received from sales, calculated as price multiplied by quantity. | Calculate $P_AQ_A+P_BQ_B$ under price discrimination. |
Profit | The difference between total revenue and total cost. | Compare profit under discriminatory pricing with profit under a single-price strategy. |
Hints from the Examiner Reports 💡
Examiner hint: Do not just draw a diagram. AQA's June 2024 guidance emphasised that an unused diagram is much less valuable than one that is explicitly explained and integrated into a logical chain of analysis. Refer directly to the prices and quantities you have labelled.
Examiner hint: Consider both the higher-price and lower-price groups. The June 2024 report found that weaker price-discrimination answers often focused only on consumers paying higher prices and ignored consumers who might receive lower prices.
Examiner hint: Use diagrams to develop the theory rather than replacing it. In June 2024, the strongest price-discrimination responses skilfully combined theoretical analysis, relevant contexts and a range of effectively used diagrams.
Examiner hint: Diagram quality matters. The November 2020 report noted considerable variation in the quality of price-discrimination diagrams, while stronger responses used their diagrams effectively to develop analysis and support conclusions.
Common Mistakes ⚠️
Mistake: Charging the same price in both diagrams
Why this is incorrect: The purpose of the model is to show how different demand conditions allow different profit-maximising prices.
How to improve: Clearly label:
$$P_A$$
and:
$$P_B$$
and explain why they differ.
Mistake: Charging the higher price in the more elastic market
Why this is incorrect: Consumers with more elastic demand are more responsive to price changes.
How to improve: Remember:
less elastic → higher price
more elastic → lower price
Mistake: Finding price where MC = MR
Why this is incorrect: $MC=MR$ determines output, not price.
How to improve: Use:
$$MC=MR\rightarrow Q\rightarrow AR\rightarrow P$$
for each market.
Mistake: Reading price from MR
Why this is incorrect: MR is not the price paid by consumers.
How to improve: After finding output, move vertically to the relevant AR curve to identify price.
Mistake: Adding the two prices to calculate total revenue
Why this is incorrect: Revenue depends on both price and quantity.
How to improve:
$$TR_A=P_AQ_A$$
$$TR_B=P_BQ_B$$
then:
$$TR_T=TR_A+TR_B$$
Mistake: Saying increased revenue is the same as increased profit
Why this is incorrect: Profit also depends on total costs.
How to improve:
$$\text{Profit}=TR-TC$$
Calculate costs before identifying the change in profit.
Mistake: Assuming total output must always increase
Why this is incorrect: AQA recognises higher output as a possible outcome of price discrimination, but the result depends on demand and cost conditions.
How to improve: Use qualified wording:
"Price discrimination may increase total output by allowing a lower price to be charged to a relatively elastic market."
Mistake: Comparing price discrimination only with perfect competition
Why this is incorrect: The most useful comparison is often with the same monopolist charging a single price.
How to improve: Compare:
single-price monopolist
with:
price-discriminating monopolist.
Mistake: Drawing two markets but not explaining their different elasticities
Why this is incorrect: Different price elasticities are central to explaining why the discriminatory prices differ.
How to improve: State clearly which market is relatively more elastic and use this to explain the price difference.
Exam-Style Questions ✍️
Question 1
State the rule used to determine the profit-maximising output sold in each separated market in a simplified price-discrimination model. [1 mark]
Answer:
$$MC=MR$$
Question 2
Market A has relatively price-inelastic demand and Market B has relatively price-elastic demand.
State which market is likely to face the higher discriminatory price. [1 mark]
Answer:
Market A, because its demand is relatively less price elastic.
Question 3
Explain why a price-discriminating firm is likely to charge a higher price in a market where demand is relatively price inelastic. [4 marks]
Indicative answer:
Consumers with relatively price-inelastic demand are less responsive to a change in price. A price increase therefore produces a proportionately smaller reduction in quantity demanded. A firm with monopoly power can consequently charge this group a relatively higher price and potentially increase the revenue and profit obtained from that market.
Question 4
A firm price discriminates between two markets.
In Market A:
$$P_A=£25$$
$$Q_A=400$$
In Market B:
$$P_B=£12$$
$$Q_B=700$$
Calculate the firm's total revenue. [4 marks]
Answer:
Market A:
$$TR_A=£25\times400$$
$$TR_A=£10,000$$
Market B:
$$TR_B=£12\times700$$
$$TR_B=£8,400$$
Total revenue:
$$TR_T=£10,000+£8,400$$
$$TR_T=£18,400$$
Answer: £18,400
Question 5
The firm in Question 4 has total costs of £11,600.
Calculate its profit. [3 marks]
Answer:
$$\text{Profit}=TR-TC$$
$$\text{Profit}=£18,400-£11,600$$
$$\text{Profit}=£6,800$$
Answer: £6,800
Question 6
Using your answers to Questions 4 and 5, calculate the change in revenue, output and profit following price discrimination. [6 marks]
Answer:
Single-price revenue
$$TR_S=£18\times900$$
$$TR_S=£16,200$$
Single-price profit:
$$£16,200-£10,000=£6,200$$
Price discrimination
Revenue:
$$£18,400$$
Profit:
$$£6,800$$
Output:
$$400+700=1,100$$
Changes
Revenue:
$$£18,400-£16,200=£2,200$$
Revenue rises by £2,200.
Output:
$$1,100-900=200$$
Output rises by 200 units.
Profit:
$$£6,800-£6,200=£600$$
Profit rises by £600.
Notice that the increase in revenue is larger than the increase in profit because total costs have also increased.
Question 7
With the help of diagrams, analyse how a firm may charge different prices to two groups with different price elasticities of demand. [9 marks]
Indicative answer:
A strong response may include:
definition of price discrimination
recognition that the markets must be separable
two separate diagrams
Market A with relatively less elastic $AR_A$
Market B with relatively more elastic $AR_B$
MR below AR in both markets
common marginal cost in a simplified model
output in Market A found where:
$$MR_A=MC$$
output in Market B found where:
$$MR_B=MC$$
$P_A$ read from $AR_A$
$P_B$ read from $AR_B$
explanation that:
$$P_A>P_B$$
because consumers in Market A are less responsive to price
explanation that the firm can therefore obtain greater revenue from consumers with relatively inelastic demand while using a lower price to encourage sales in the more elastic market.
Question 8
Explain, with the help of diagrams, how price discrimination may affect a firm's prices, output, revenue and profit compared with charging a single monopoly price. [15 marks]
Indicative mark scheme:
A strong response may include:
definition of price discrimination
appropriate conditions for successful discrimination
identification of separate market segments
differences in price elasticity of demand
construction of separate AR and MR curves
relatively inelastic demand in one market
relatively elastic demand in another
use of:
$$MR=MC$$
to determine output in each market
price identified from the relevant AR curve
higher price in the relatively inelastic market
lower price in the relatively elastic market
comparison with a single monopoly price
explanation that some consumers may face a price above the single price
explanation that other consumers may face a price below the single price
possibility that lower prices attract additional consumers
possibility of greater total output
calculation or explanation of producer revenue:
$$TR_D=P_AQ_A+P_BQ_B$$
comparison with single-price revenue:
$$TR_S=P_SQ_S$$
explanation of how price discrimination may convert consumer surplus into producer revenue
explanation that successful discrimination may increase total revenue
distinction between revenue and profit
correct use of:
$$\text{Profit}=TR-TC$$
recognition that increased output or market segmentation may also affect total costs.
A useful chain is:
different elasticities → market separation → different profit-maximising prices → higher price to less elastic consumers + lower price to more elastic consumers → greater extraction of willingness to pay + possible additional sales → increased producer revenue → potentially higher profit
Higher-level response: Accurate and clearly labelled diagrams, correct use of $MR=MC$, strong explanation of why prices differ, and developed analysis of changes in output, revenue and profit.
Middle-level response: Reasonable price-discrimination diagrams and understanding of different prices, but the analysis of revenue, output or profit may be incomplete.
Lower-level response: Basic recognition that different consumers pay different prices, with inaccurate or unused diagrams and limited understanding of elasticity, $MC=MR$, revenue or profit.

Comments