Price discrimination | AQA A-Level Economics
For Specification 7136
AQA A-Level Economics | Free Revision Notes
Estimated study time: 45 to 55 minutes
Price discrimination allows a firm with market power to charge different prices for essentially the same product to different consumers or markets. In this Price discrimination A-Level Economics revision page, you will learn the conditions that make price discrimination possible, apply the theory to real-world examples and explain why firms may prefer discriminatory pricing to charging everyone a single price. The topic builds directly on monopoly power [Monopoly power]. Formal diagrams are developed next in diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination [Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination].
Learning Objectives 🎯
By the end of this revision page, you should be able to:
Define price discrimination.
Explain the conditions necessary for a firm to price discriminate.
Explain why monopoly power is important for price discrimination.
Analyse the importance of separating markets and preventing resale.
Apply price discrimination to real-world examples.
Explain why firms may use price discrimination to increase revenue, profit or capacity utilisation.
Revision Notes 📚
Price discrimination A-Level Economics revision
Price discrimination occurs when a firm charges different prices for essentially the same product to different consumers or groups of consumers, where the price difference is not simply explained by differences in the cost of supplying them.
AQA requires students to understand:
the conditions necessary for price discrimination
its advantages and disadvantages
real-world examples
its impact on producers and consumers
diagrammatic analysis.
This lesson focuses on the conditions, examples and reasons firms engage in price discrimination. The diagrammatic and welfare consequences are developed in diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination [Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination] and evaluating price discrimination [Evaluating price discrimination].
Different prices do not automatically mean price discrimination
This distinction is essential.
Suppose a firm charges £20 to supply one customer but £25 to another because the second customer costs £5 more to serve.
The price difference may reflect a genuine difference in cost.
That is not necessarily price discrimination.
For price discrimination, the different prices must relate to essentially the same product and cannot simply be explained by different production or supply costs.
AQA's specimen mark scheme explicitly distinguishes price discrimination from price differences caused by factors such as transport costs.
Simple example
Suppose the same service costs a firm £10 to provide to both Consumer A and Consumer B.
The firm charges:
$$P_A=£25$$
and:
$$P_B=£15$$
If the different prices result from differences in the consumers' willingness to pay rather than differences in supply costs, this is consistent with price discrimination.
The basic idea
Instead of:
one product → one price for everyone
the firm uses:
same or essentially the same product → different prices for different consumers or markets
The firm does this because consumers may differ in their:
willingness to pay
responsiveness to price
ability to switch between markets.
The conditions necessary for price discrimination
AQA mark schemes identify several conditions that make price discrimination possible, including:
monopoly power
the ability to segment or separate markets
the ability to prevent cross-selling between market segments
differences in price elasticity of demand.
These conditions work together.
Condition 1: The firm must have some monopoly power
A firm needs a degree of monopoly power to influence the price it charges.
A perfectly competitive firm is a price taker.
It therefore cannot independently decide to charge different consumers different prices while identical products remain available at the market price.
A firm with monopoly power has more influence over its pricing decisions.
The chain is:
monopoly power
↓
firm is a price maker rather than a pure price taker
↓
firm has some control over the prices charged
↓
different prices can potentially be charged to different market segments
This connects directly to monopoly power [Monopoly power].
Monopoly power does not require pure monopoly
The firm does not have to be the only supplier in existence.
As you learned previously, firms operating in:
monopolistic competition
oligopoly
can also possess varying degrees of monopoly power.
Therefore, price discrimination is not restricted to a pure monopolist.
The important condition is that the firm has enough market power to influence price.
Why a price taker cannot easily discriminate
Imagine a perfectly competitive market price of:
$$£10$$
If one firm attempted to charge a particular group:
$$£15$$
for an identical product, those consumers could simply purchase it from other suppliers for £10.
The firm lacks the necessary pricing power.
By contrast, a firm with monopoly power may have greater ability to charge different prices.
Condition 2: The firm must be able to separate the market
The firm must be able to segment the market into different groups.
AQA's 2024 mark scheme explicitly identifies the ability to segment the market as a condition for price discrimination.
Market segmentation means identifying groups of consumers who can be charged differently.
The separation might be based on factors such as:
the market in which the product is sold
the time at which the product or service is purchased or consumed
whether the customer is an existing or new customer.
These examples are reflected in AQA assessment material, including international pricing, peak and off-peak travel, and different prices for existing and new telecommunications customers.
Why segmentation matters
Suppose a firm knows there are two groups.
Group A
Consumers are willing to pay relatively high prices.
Group B
Consumers are more responsive to price and will only buy at a lower price.
If the firm can identify and separate the groups, it may charge:
$$P_A>P_B$$
If it cannot distinguish the consumers, it may have to charge a single price.
Market separation chain
consumers have different demand characteristics
↓
firm identifies separate groups
↓
firm prevents the groups from effectively becoming one market
↓
different prices can be charged
Market segmentation is therefore central to successful price discrimination.
Condition 3: Resale between markets must be prevented
The firm must be able to prevent or substantially restrict consumers from buying at the low price and reselling to consumers who face the high price.
AQA's 2024 mark scheme explicitly refers to the need to prevent cross-selling between market segments.
Why resale creates a problem
Suppose a firm charges:
$$£10$$
in Market A and:
$$£20$$
in Market B.
If consumers in Market A can freely buy the product for £10 and resell it to people in Market B for £15:
Market A consumers can earn £5 per unit
Market B consumers save £5
the original producer loses its ability to charge £20 in Market B.
The two prices become difficult to maintain.
Resale chain
low-price market
↓
customers buy product cheaply
↓
customers resell into high-price market
↓
high-price consumers avoid buying from original firm
↓
price discrimination breaks down
Therefore, the producer needs some way of keeping the market segments separate.
Services can sometimes be easier to separate
Some services are difficult to resell.
For example, a journey bought for a particular individual or a personal telecommunications contract cannot necessarily be transferred freely to another consumer.
This can make market separation easier than for a product that can be easily purchased and resold.
The exam skill is not to memorise a fixed list. Instead ask:
Can customers in the cheaper market resell effectively to customers in the expensive market?
Condition 4: Consumers should have different price elasticities of demand
Differences in price elasticity of demand (PED) help explain why charging different prices may increase a firm's revenue and profit.
Price elasticity of demand measures the responsiveness of quantity demanded to a change in price.
You studied this in price elasticity of demand [Price elasticity of demand].
AQA's specimen and 2024 mark schemes both identify differences in PED as important to price-discrimination analysis.
Relatively inelastic demand
Consumers with relatively price-inelastic demand are less responsive to a price change.
A firm may therefore be able to charge these consumers a higher price.
For example, if:
$$PED=-0.4$$
a 10% increase in price would, other things equal, produce a proportionately smaller fall in quantity demanded.
Relatively elastic demand
Consumers with relatively price-elastic demand are more responsive to price.
A lower price may be needed to attract or retain these consumers.
For example:
$$PED=-2.0$$
means quantity demanded is relatively responsive to changes in price.
The basic price-discrimination relationship
In general:
relatively inelastic demand → higher price
relatively elastic demand → lower price
This is one of the most important relationships in the topic.
Why different elasticities matter
Suppose two groups are currently being charged the same price.
Group A has relatively inelastic demand.
Group B has relatively elastic demand.
The firm may be able to increase revenue by:
charging Group A more
charging Group B less.
A single uniform price may therefore be less profitable than separate prices tailored to the demand conditions of each market.
The formal diagrammatic analysis of this is developed in diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination [Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination].
Bringing the conditions together
Successful price discrimination normally requires the firm to satisfy several conditions at the same time.
A useful chain is:
sufficient monopoly power
↓
ability to influence price
ability to identify separate consumer groups
↓
different prices can be targeted
different price elasticities of demand
↓
different profit-maximising prices may be appropriate
prevention of resale
↓
price differences can be maintained
Conditions checklist
When given an unfamiliar example, ask:
Does the firm have monopoly power?
Can it identify different markets or consumer groups?
Do those groups have different demand characteristics?
Can consumers in the cheaper market be prevented from reselling to the expensive market?
If these conditions are met, price discrimination becomes much more feasible.
Real-world examples of price discrimination
AQA specifically requires students to be aware of real-world examples.
The important exam skill is not simply to list examples.
For each example, explain:
how the market is segmented
why consumers may have different elasticities
how resale is restricted.
Example 1: Peak and off-peak rail fares
AQA assessment material explicitly uses peak and off-peak rail fares as an example of price discrimination.
A rail operator may charge:
a higher fare at peak times
a lower fare at off-peak times.
Why might demand differ?
Some peak-time passengers may have less flexibility over when they travel.
Their demand may therefore be relatively less price elastic.
Off-peak passengers may have greater flexibility and be more sensitive to price.
Therefore:
peak travellers → relatively less elastic demand → higher price
off-peak travellers → relatively more elastic demand → lower price
Why can the markets be separated?
The ticket can specify:
when it is valid
the journey for which it is valid.
This helps prevent a consumer from simply purchasing an off-peak ticket and using it during the restricted peak period.
Why might the firm do this?
AQA's specimen mark scheme identifies peak and off-peak pricing as potentially allowing demand to be spread more evenly, improving capacity utilisation.
The chain is:
lower off-peak price
↓
more consumers encouraged to travel off-peak
↓
demand becomes more evenly distributed
↓
existing capacity may be used more fully
Example 2: Existing and new telecommunications customers
The June 2024 AQA Paper 1 used broadband and mobile phone companies as a context.
The question referred to situations where existing customers were charged higher prices than new customers.
This provides a useful example of firms separating consumers according to customer status.
Possible reasoning is:
existing customers may be less likely to switch
↓
their demand may be relatively less responsive to price
↓
firms may be able to charge them a higher price
while:
new customers may compare competing offers more actively
↓
lower introductory price may be needed to attract them
The 2024 mark scheme also recognised that technology and customer data can make market segmentation easier.
Example 3: Different geographical markets
AQA's specimen paper used the example of the same technology products being sold at different prices in the USA and UK while being sourced from the same factories.
This illustrates geographical market segmentation.
If the firm can maintain different prices between countries and prevent effective cross-selling, different demand conditions may allow separate prices to persist.
However, be careful:
different prices between countries do not automatically prove price discrimination.
The price difference could instead reflect:
transportation costs
other differences in costs.
A strong answer must establish that the price difference is not simply due to differences in the cost of supplying the market.
Example 4: Last-minute holiday bookings
AQA's November 2020 mark scheme gives last-minute holiday bookings as an example where some consumers may benefit from lower prices through price discrimination.
This illustrates how a firm may charge different consumers different prices depending on demand conditions and timing.
It also shows that price discrimination does not necessarily mean every consumer pays more.
Some groups may receive a lower price than under a single-price system.
A good example needs economic explanation
Weak exam application:
"Train companies use price discrimination."
Stronger application:
"A rail operator may charge higher peak fares to commuters whose demand is relatively price inelastic because they have less flexibility over travel time. Off-peak passengers may have more elastic demand and can be attracted by lower fares. Ticket restrictions help separate the two markets and prevent consumers from simply using the cheaper fare at peak times."
The second answer uses the example to demonstrate the theory.
Why do firms engage in price discrimination?
The main motivation is usually to increase the firm's revenue and profit compared with charging a single price.
AQA's specimen mark scheme explicitly recognises that price discrimination can allow producers to increase revenue and profit.
Reason 1: Increase revenue
Different groups have different willingness to pay.
A single price cannot exploit these differences fully.
Suppose:
some consumers would pay £30
others would only buy at £15.
A single price of £30 excludes the second group.
A single price of £15 means the firm receives only £15 from consumers who were prepared to pay £30.
If the firm can separate the groups, it might charge:
$$£30$$
to the first group and:
$$£15$$
to the second.
Revenue may therefore increase.
Numerical example
Suppose there are:
100 consumers willing to pay £30
100 consumers willing to pay £15.
Single price of £30
Only the first group buys:
$$TR=100\times£30=£3,000$$
Single price of £15
Both groups buy:
$$TR=200\times£15=£3,000$$
Price discrimination
Charge the first group £30:
$$100\times£30=£3,000$$
Charge the second group £15:
$$100\times£15=£1,500$$
Total revenue:
$$£3,000+£1,500=£4,500$$
In this simplified example, price discrimination increases revenue from £3,000 to £4,500.
Reason 2: Increase profit
Higher revenue may result in higher profit.
Recall:
$$\text{Profit}=TR-TC$$
If price discrimination raises total revenue by more than any additional costs associated with identifying and separating consumers:
$$\text{Profit may increase}$$
This gives firms a strong incentive to price discriminate.
However, increased revenue does not automatically guarantee increased profit if the pricing system creates substantial extra costs.
Reason 3: Capture more consumer surplus
Consumer surplus is the difference between the price a consumer is willing to pay and the price actually paid.
AQA's specimen mark scheme recognises that price discrimination may allow producers to convert some consumer surplus into producer surplus.
Suppose a consumer would pay £20 but the single market price is £12.
Their consumer surplus is:
$$£20-£12=£8$$
If the firm can identify that willingness to pay and charge £18 instead:
$$\text{Consumer surplus}=£20-£18=£2$$
More of the value is captured by the producer.
The full welfare analysis belongs to evaluating price discrimination [Evaluating price discrimination].
Reason 4: Increase total sales
Charging a lower price to a price-sensitive group may bring additional consumers into the market.
For example:
high single price
↓
some consumers cannot or will not buy
but:
lower discriminatory price for elastic segment
↓
additional purchases
↓
greater total output and sales
AQA's specimen mark scheme recognises increased total sales as a possible consequence of price discrimination.
Reason 5: Improve capacity utilisation
Price discrimination can help a firm spread demand more evenly.
This is particularly relevant where capacity cannot easily be stored for later use.
The peak and off-peak rail example illustrates the mechanism:
lower off-peak price
↓
some demand encouraged away from peak periods
↓
more off-peak capacity is used
↓
capacity utilisation improves
AQA's specimen mark scheme specifically identifies improved capacity utilisation as a possible reason for discriminatory pricing.
Reason 6: Lower average costs through greater output
If lower prices in some market segments increase total sales:
price discrimination
↓
greater total output
↓
fixed costs spread across more units
↓
average cost may fall
AQA's specimen mark scheme recognises that increased sales from price discrimination may generate economies of scale.
This connects to economies of scale [Economies of scale].
Reason 7: Cross-subsidisation
AQA assessment material also recognises that price discrimination can allow firms to cross-subsidise loss-making services.
Cross-subsidisation occurs when revenue generated from one activity or group helps support another activity or group.
For example:
higher price charged to one segment
↓
greater revenue generated
↓
revenue helps support another service or customer group
↓
that service may continue to be supplied
This can be important when some parts of a service would otherwise be unprofitable.
Reason 8: Protect market position
AQA's specimen mark scheme also recognises the possible use of price discrimination as a barrier to entry.
A firm may charge particularly competitive prices in part of a market where it faces a threat from rivals while maintaining higher prices elsewhere.
This can make entry or expansion by competitors more difficult.
For Lesson 62, you only need the basic link:
targeted lower price in contested segment → stronger competitive response → entry may become less attractive
The wider relationship between barriers to entry and market power was studied in monopoly power [Monopoly power].
Price discrimination and profit maximisation
Price discrimination does not replace the firm's profit-maximising objective.
Instead, it changes the pricing strategy available to the firm.
A single-price firm uses one set of demand and revenue conditions.
A price-discriminating firm separates markets and can take account of different demand conditions in each segment.
This may allow the firm to achieve greater total profit.
The formal $MC=MR$ analysis across separate markets is developed in diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination [Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination].
Different elasticities are central
A firm generally has the greatest incentive to charge a higher price in the segment with less elastic demand.
Suppose:
Market A
$$PED=-0.5$$
Market B
$$PED=-2.0$$
Market A has the less elastic demand.
Other things equal, the firm has greater scope to charge a higher price in Market A because consumers there are less responsive to price changes.
Therefore:
$$P_A>P_B$$
may be profitable.
Do not simply memorise "inelastic = high price"
You should explain why.
A developed chain is:
demand relatively inelastic
↓
consumers are less responsive to a price rise
↓
quantity demanded falls proportionately less
↓
firm can charge a relatively higher price without losing as many sales
↓
greater revenue and profit may be extracted from that segment
Technology and price discrimination
The June 2024 AQA mark scheme recognised the importance of technology, particularly the internet, in making some markets more susceptible to price discrimination through improved collection of customer data.
The mechanism is:
more customer information
↓
firms can identify consumer characteristics or behaviour more effectively
↓
market segmentation becomes easier
↓
different prices can be targeted more accurately
This creates a useful link back to imperfect and asymmetric information [Imperfect and asymmetric information].
For this lesson, the key point is simply that better information can make segmentation easier.
Price discrimination and a single-price alternative
When analysing why a firm uses price discrimination, the correct comparison is often with the same firm charging a single price.
Suppose the firm can either:
charge every consumer £20
charge one segment £30 and another £15.
The firm will compare the revenue and profit generated by the alternatives.
This is important because the relevant alternative to price discrimination is not automatically perfect competition.
AQA mark schemes explicitly recognise comparisons with a non-discriminating monopolist.
Conditions and motives are different
Do not mix these up.
Conditions answer:
What must be true for price discrimination to be possible?
sufficient monopoly power
identifiable market segments
different demand conditions
prevention of resale.
Motives answer:
Why would the firm want to do it?
increase revenue
increase profit
capture consumer surplus
increase sales
improve capacity utilisation
support cross-subsidisation
potentially strengthen its market position.
This distinction is extremely useful in examination questions.
Real-world application checklist
When given a pricing example, work through four stages.
1. Is the product essentially the same?
If the products are genuinely different, different prices may simply reflect different products.
2. Are the cost differences significant?
If one group costs much more to serve, the higher price may simply reflect higher costs.
3. Can the consumers be separated?
Look for:
different locations
different times
different customer groups.
4. Can resale be prevented?
If consumers can easily buy cheaply and resell, sustained price discrimination becomes difficult.
If all four conditions support the theory, the example is much stronger.
Comparing single pricing and price discrimination
Single pricing | Price discrimination |
One price charged across consumers or markets | Different prices charged to separate groups |
Does not exploit differences in willingness to pay as precisely | Prices can reflect different demand elasticities |
Some high-willingness-to-pay consumers retain consumer surplus | Firm may capture more consumer surplus |
Some price-sensitive consumers may not buy | Lower prices may attract additional consumers |
Simpler pricing system | Requires segmentation and prevention of resale |
The detailed effects on consumers and producers are developed in evaluating price discrimination [Evaluating price discrimination].
What comes next?
Lesson 62 establishes what makes price discrimination possible and why firms use it.
Next, diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination [Diagrammatic analysis of price discrimination] applies separate AR and MR curves to market segments to analyse:
prices
output
producer revenue
profit.
You will then use those results in evaluating price discrimination [Evaluating price discrimination] to examine its advantages and disadvantages for producers and consumers.
Later, monopoly, welfare and surplus [Monopoly, welfare and surplus] applies consumer and producer surplus directly to price discrimination and other monopoly outcomes.
Key Words 🔑
Key word | Student-friendly definition | How it may be used in an exam |
Price discrimination | Charging different prices for essentially the same product to different consumers or markets, where the difference is not simply explained by different costs. | Define the pricing strategy before explaining its conditions or effects. |
Market segmentation | Dividing consumers into identifiable groups that can be charged different prices. | Explain how a firm can apply different prices to different consumers. |
Cross-selling | Consumers buying in a low-price market and reselling into a higher-price market. | Explain why resale must be prevented for price discrimination to persist. |
Price elasticity of demand (PED) | The responsiveness of quantity demanded to a change in price. | Explain why firms tend to charge higher prices to groups with relatively less elastic demand. |
Cross-subsidisation | Using revenue generated from one group or activity to help finance another. | Explain one reason discriminatory pricing may allow otherwise loss-making services to continue. |
Hints from the Examiner Reports 💡
Examiner hint: Do not merely list real-world examples. The June 2024 examiner report identified this as a weakness. Stronger answers integrated examples with economic theory, explaining why the situation represented price discrimination and how consumers were affected.
Examiner hint: Avoid assuming that price discrimination simply means "some consumers pay more". In June 2024, weaker responses focused entirely on higher prices and overlooked the lower prices that may be offered to other consumer groups.
Examiner hint: Use a range of contexts where appropriate. The strongest June 2024 responses combined theoretical analysis with several well-developed examples, which gave greater support to their arguments.
Examiner hint: Recognise that price discrimination can have benefits as well as costs. The November 2020 examiner report noted that some students wrongly assumed it was always damaging, while stronger responses considered both sides and used diagrams effectively.
Common Mistakes ⚠️
Mistake: Saying every difference in price is price discrimination
Why this is incorrect: Different prices may reflect genuine differences in the cost of supplying customers.
How to improve: Check whether consumers are being charged different prices for essentially the same product without the difference being explained simply by costs.
Mistake: Saying only a pure monopoly can price discriminate
Why this is incorrect: A firm needs monopoly power, but AQA recognises that firms in several imperfectly competitive market structures may possess monopoly power.
How to improve: Write:
"The firm needs sufficient market power to influence the prices it charges."
Mistake: Forgetting market separation
Why this is incorrect: A firm cannot effectively charge separate groups differently if it cannot identify or separate those groups.
How to improve: Always include:
ability to segment the market
as a condition.
Mistake: Ignoring resale
Why this is incorrect: Consumers in the low-price market could buy and resell to consumers in the high-price market, undermining the price difference.
How to improve: Explain why cross-selling or resale must be prevented.
Mistake: Saying firms charge higher prices to consumers with more elastic demand
Why this is incorrect: More elastic consumers are more responsive to price changes.
How to improve: Remember:
less elastic demand → higher discriminatory price
more elastic demand → lower discriminatory price
Mistake: Giving examples without explaining different elasticities
Why this is incorrect: Simply writing "peak and off-peak rail fares" demonstrates little economic analysis.
How to improve: Explain why one consumer group may be less responsive to price than another.
Mistake: Assuming price discrimination always increases profit
Why this is incorrect: The firm may face costs associated with identifying and separating consumers, and the pricing strategy must actually increase revenue sufficiently to cover those costs.
How to improve: Write that price discrimination may increase profit compared with single pricing when the conditions make it effective.
Mistake: Confusing price discrimination with product differentiation
Why this is incorrect: Product differentiation means consumers perceive products as different. Price discrimination concerns different prices for essentially the same product.
How to improve: Ask whether the product itself is different, or whether the price charged to different consumers is different.
Exam-Style Questions ✍️
Question 1
Define price discrimination. [2 marks]
Answer:
Price discrimination occurs when a firm charges different prices for essentially the same product to different consumers or markets, where the price differences are not simply explained by differences in supply costs.
Question 2
State two conditions necessary for successful price discrimination. [2 marks]
Answer:
Award 1 mark each for any two appropriate conditions, including:
sufficient monopoly power
ability to separate or segment markets
different demand elasticities between consumer groups
ability to prevent resale or cross-selling between markets.
Question 3
Explain why a firm needs monopoly power to price discriminate successfully. [4 marks]
Indicative answer:
A firm with monopoly power has some ability to influence the price it charges. It can therefore charge different consumer groups different prices. A price-taking firm cannot easily do this because consumers can purchase an identical product from competitors at the market price.
Question 4
A rail operator charges £60 for a peak-time journey and £35 for the same journey during an off-peak period.
Explain two conditions that could allow this price discrimination to operate successfully. [6 marks]
Indicative answer:
Peak and off-peak travellers can be separated according to when their tickets are valid. This allows the rail operator to identify different market segments.
Resale or movement between the segments can also be restricted because an off-peak ticket cannot simply be used during the peak period.
Peak travellers may also have less elastic demand because they have less flexibility over when they travel, allowing the firm to charge them a higher price.
Question 5
Two consumer groups have the following estimated price elasticities of demand:
$$PED_A=-0.4$$
$$PED_B=-2.1$$
Explain which group a price-discriminating firm is likely to charge the higher price. [4 marks]
Answer:
Group A is likely to be charged the higher price because its demand is relatively price inelastic.
Consumers in Group A are less responsive to a change in price, so the firm can raise their price with a proportionately smaller reduction in quantity demanded.
Group B has relatively elastic demand and is therefore more likely to be offered the lower price.
Question 6
A firm has 200 customers who are willing to pay £40 and 300 customers who will only buy if the price is £20.
Calculate the firm's revenue from:
a) charging everyone £20
b) charging the two groups £40 and £20 respectively. [5 marks]
Answer:
a) Single price of £20
All 500 customers purchase:
$$TR=500\times£20$$
$$TR=£10,000$$
b) Price discrimination
First group:
$$200\times£40=£8,000$$
Second group:
$$300\times£20=£6,000$$
Total:
$$TR=£8,000+£6,000$$
$$TR=£14,000$$
Revenue is therefore:
$$£14,000-£10,000=£4,000$$
higher under price discrimination in this simplified example.
Question 7
A broadband provider charges existing customers £38 per month while offering new customers an introductory price of £25 per month.
Analyse how this could represent price discrimination and why the provider may adopt this strategy. [9 marks]
Indicative answer:
The provider is separating customers according to whether they are existing or new customers. If the service supplied is essentially the same and the price difference is not explained by different costs, this may represent price discrimination.
Existing customers may be less likely to switch provider and therefore have relatively less elastic demand. The firm may be able to charge them £38 without losing many customers.
Potential new customers may compare competing offers more closely and have more elastic demand, so the £25 introductory price can help attract them.
By charging each group differently, the provider may earn greater total revenue and profit than if it were required to charge every customer the same price.
Question 8
Explain why a firm with monopoly power may choose to price discriminate rather than charge a single price to all consumers. [15 marks]
Indicative mark scheme:
A strong response may include:
definition of price discrimination
distinction between discriminatory pricing and cost-based price differences
requirement for monopoly power
ability to separate or segment markets
prevention of resale or cross-selling
differences in price elasticity of demand
higher prices for groups with relatively inelastic demand
lower prices for groups with relatively elastic demand
increased revenue
possible increase in profit
capture of additional consumer surplus
increased sales to consumers who would not purchase at the higher single price
improved capacity utilisation
potential economies of scale from increased output
cross-subsidisation
possible use as a barrier to entry
appropriate real-world examples such as peak and off-peak rail travel, existing and new telecommunications customers or different geographical markets.
A strong analytical chain might be:
different consumer elasticities
↓
firm separates the markets
↓
higher price charged where demand is less elastic
and:
lower price charged where demand is more elastic
↓
more of consumers' differing willingness to pay is captured
↓
total revenue and potentially profit increase relative to a single-price strategy
Higher-level response: Sound understanding of the conditions required, accurate use of price elasticity of demand, well-developed explanation of why discriminatory pricing may increase revenue or profit, and examples that are integrated into the economic analysis.
Middle-level response: Reasonable knowledge of price discrimination and some relevant conditions or motives, but links to elasticity, market separation or revenue may be underdeveloped.
Lower-level response: Basic description of firms charging different prices, with limited explanation of monopoly power, market segmentation, prevention of resale or why the strategy may benefit the firm.

Comments