top of page

Monopsony in the labour market | AQA A-Level Economics

7 hours ago
14 min read

For Specification 7136


AQA A-Level Economics | Free Revision Notes


Estimated study time: 45–55 minutes


Monopsony in the labour market A-Level Economics revision examines what happens when an employer has market power over workers. For AQA 7136, you need to understand how monopsony contributes to labour-market imperfection and how an employer can use this power to reduce both wages and employment below competitive levels. Diagrammatic analysis is explicitly required. This lesson develops the competitive benchmark from wage determination [Perfectly competitive labour markets] and relative wages [Relative wage rates], before considering how worker bargaining power may alter monopsony outcomes in trade unions and monopsony [Trade unions and monopsony].


Learning Objectives 🎯


By the end of this revision page, you should be able to:

  • Define monopsony and explain monopsony power in a labour market.

  • Explain why a monopsonistic employer faces an upward-sloping labour-supply curve.

  • Explain the relationship between the supply of labour and the marginal cost of labour.

  • Construct and interpret a monopsony labour-market diagram.

  • Determine the monopsony wage and level of employment.

  • Compare monopsony wages and employment with the outcome in a perfectly competitive labour market.


Revision Notes 📚


Monopsony in the labour market: A-Level Economics revision essentials


AQA identifies monopsony power as one of the factors that can make a labour market imperfectly competitive.


The specification requires you to understand how a monopsony employer can use market power to reduce:

  • the relative wage rate; and

  • the level of employment

below the levels that would exist in a perfectly competitive labour market. AQA also states that relevant diagrams are expected.


This means you need to do more than define monopsony. You must be able to compare the monopsony outcome with the competitive benchmark.


What is monopsony?


A monopsony is a market in which there is a single or dominant buyer.


In a labour market, the buyer is the employer, because firms buy labour services from workers.

A monopsonistic employer therefore has substantial buying power in the labour market.


This contrasts with the benchmark studied in Perfectly competitive labour markets [Perfectly competitive labour markets], where market forces determine the wage and individual employers do not possess significant power to hold wages below the competitive level.


Monopsony power


Monopsony power is the ability of an employer to influence the wage and employment outcome because workers have limited alternative employers competing for their labour.


The central AQA point is:


Employer market power can allow wages and employment to be lower than they would be under perfect competition.

This makes monopsony a form of labour-market imperfection.


AQA has used public-sector employment as an applied context for monopsony. In the November 2020 assessment, the social-care context described the government as a monopsonistic employer when almost all care-sector workers were employed by the public sector.


Competitive labour-market benchmark


Before constructing the monopsony model, recall the competitive equilibrium.

Wage rate
   |
   |       S_L
Wc |------Ec
   |     /  \
   |    /    \
   |   /      \ MRP = D_L
   +---------------------- Labour
            Lc

The competitive equilibrium occurs where:


$$S_L = D_L$$


or, using marginal productivity theory:


$$S_L = MRP_L$$


The equilibrium gives:

  • competitive wage $$W_c$$;

  • competitive employment $$L_c$$.


This provides the benchmark against which monopsony is judged.


The monopsonist faces the labour-supply curve


A monopsonistic employer faces an upward-sloping supply curve of labour.


This means that to attract a greater quantity of labour, the employer must offer a higher wage.


The labour-supply curve therefore shows the wage required to attract each level of employment.


It can also be treated as the employer's average cost of labour (ACL).

Wage / labour cost
   |
   |        / S_L = ACL
   |       /
   |      /
   |     /
   |    /
   +---------------------- Labour

The upward slope reflects the relationship already studied in occupational labour supply [The supply of labour to occupations]: more workers are willing to supply labour at higher wage rates.


Why marginal cost of labour is above labour supply


For the standard monopsony model, another curve is needed: the marginal cost of labour (MCL).


Marginal cost of labour is the additional labour cost resulting from employing another unit of labour.


It can be expressed as:


$$MCL = \frac{\Delta TLC}{\Delta L}$$


where:

  • $$MCL$$ = marginal cost of labour;

  • $$\Delta TLC$$ = change in total labour cost;

  • $$\Delta L$$ = change in employment.


In the standard monopsony model, the marginal cost of employing an additional worker is above the wage shown on the labour-supply curve.


Why?


Suppose an employer must raise the wage to attract another worker. If it pays the same wage to its existing workers, increasing employment raises the wage cost associated with the workforce as well as adding another worker.


The additional cost of labour is therefore greater than the wage paid to the marginal worker.


Consequently:


$$MCL > ACL$$


and the MCL curve lies above the labour-supply curve.


The monopsony diagram


A standard monopsony labour-market diagram contains three important curves:

  • labour supply, also showing the wage required to attract workers;

  • marginal cost of labour (MCL);

  • marginal revenue product (MRP), which represents labour demand.

Wage /
labour cost
   |
   |          MCL
   |         /
Wc |--------/------Ec
   |       /      / \
   |      /      /   \ MRP
Wm |-----A------/     \
   |    /|     /
   |   / |    /
   |  /  |   / S_L
   +-------------------------- Labour
       Lm       Lc

The diagram must be interpreted in two separate stages:

  1. determine how many workers the monopsonist employs;

  2. determine what wage those workers receive.


This distinction is essential.


Step 1: determine monopsony employment


The monopsonistic employer chooses employment where:


$$MCL = MRP$$


This determines employment at:


$$L_m$$


The logic is marginal.


Before this point, an additional worker adds more to revenue than to labour cost.


Beyond this point, the marginal cost of another worker exceeds their marginal revenue product.


The monopsonist therefore stops expanding employment where:


$$MCL = MRP$$


This applies the same marginal reasoning used earlier in The demand for labour [The demand for labour].


Step 2: determine the monopsony wage


A very common error is to read the wage directly from the intersection of MCL and MRP.


That intersection determines employment, not the wage.


Once employment $$L_m$$ has been found:

  1. move vertically down from the MCL = MRP intersection to the labour-supply curve;

  2. read the corresponding wage from the vertical axis.


This gives:


$$W_m$$


The monopsony therefore employs $$L_m$$ workers and pays wage $$W_m$$.


Why does the wage come from the supply curve?


The labour-supply curve tells the employer the wage required to attract a particular number of workers.


If the monopsonist wants to employ $$L_m$$ workers, it only needs to pay the wage corresponding to $$L_m$$ on the supply curve.


The MCL curve tells us the marginal cost of changing employment, not the actual wage paid.


This distinction is one of the most important features of the monopsony model.


The competitive outcome


To find the perfectly competitive benchmark, ignore the MCL curve.


Competitive equilibrium occurs where labour supply intersects labour demand:


$$S_L = MRP$$


This gives:

  • employment $$L_c$$;

  • wage $$W_c$$.


The standard model predicts:


$$L_m < L_c$$


and:


$$W_m < W_c$$


Therefore, compared with a perfectly competitive labour market, monopsony produces:

  • lower employment;

  • lower wages.


This is exactly the outcome identified in the AQA specification.


Comparing monopsony and perfect competition

Outcome

Perfect competition

Monopsony

Employment

$$L_c$$

$$L_m$$

Wage

$$W_c$$

$$W_m$$

Employment comparison

Higher

Lower

Wage comparison

Higher

Lower

Employer labour-market power

Limited

Significant


The key relationships are:


$$W_m < W_c$$


and:


$$L_m < L_c$$


AQA's November 2020 mark scheme explicitly expected students to show monopsony employment and wages below their perfectly competitive levels.


Wage below marginal revenue product


At monopsony employment $$L_m$$, the worker's marginal revenue product is above the wage paid.


The employer chooses $$L_m$$ where:


$$MCL = MRP$$


but pays the lower wage given by the labour-supply curve.


Therefore:


$$W_m < MRP$$


for the marginal worker at the monopsony employment level.


The November 2020 mark scheme specifically identified a wage below the MRP of the workers employed as a feature of the monopsony outcome.


Why can monopsony reduce wages?


Consider the competitive market first.


With many employers competing for labour, an employer that offers too little may find it difficult to recruit workers because workers have alternatives.


With strong monopsony power, workers have less bargaining power relative to the employer.


The employer can therefore restrict its demand for labour.


The analytical chain is:


Employer has monopsony power → restricts employment below competitive level → moves to a lower point on the labour-supply curve → lower wage is required to attract this smaller workforce → wage falls below competitive level.


This is why monopsony affects both employment and pay.


Why can monopsony reduce employment?


The monopsonist does not employ labour up to the competitive point where:


$$S_L = MRP$$


Instead, it chooses employment where:


$$MCL = MRP$$


Because the MCL curve lies above the supply curve, this intersection occurs at a smaller quantity of labour.


Therefore:


$$L_m < L_c$$


The restriction of employment is central to the model.


AQA's 2025 mark scheme also recognised that monopsony employers are likely to employ fewer workers than employers in more competitive labour markets.


Worked example: deriving the monopsony outcome


Suppose a monopsonistic employer faces the following simplified labour-market conditions.

Workers employed

Wage required per worker per shift

Total labour cost

Marginal cost of labour

Marginal revenue product

1

£20

£20

£20

£100

2

£30

£60

£40

£80

3

£40

£120

£60

£60

4

£50

£200

£80

£50

5

£60

£300

£100

£40


Step 1: find monopsony employment


The monopsonist employs labour where:


$$MCL = MRP$$


At three workers:


$$MCL = £60$$


and:


$$MRP = £60$$


Therefore:


$$L_m = 3$$


workers.


Step 2: find the wage


At three workers, the labour-supply schedule shows that the wage required is:


$$W_m = £40$$


Therefore the monopsony outcome is:


$$L_m = 3$$


and:


$$W_m = £40$$


per shift.


Finding the competitive outcome from the same data


In a competitive labour market, compare the wage required to attract labour with marginal revenue product.


At four workers:


$$W = £50$$


and:


$$MRP = £50$$


Therefore the competitive outcome is:


$$L_c = 4$$


and:


$$W_c = £50$$


Comparing the two:


$$L_m = 3 < 4 = L_c$$


and:


$$W_m = £40 < £50 = W_c$$


The numerical example therefore reproduces the result predicted by the monopsony model.


Calculating the wage difference


The difference between the competitive and monopsony wage is:


$$£50 - £40 = £10$$


The monopsony wage is £10 per shift below the competitive wage in this hypothetical example.


The difference in employment is:


$$4 - 3 = 1$$


worker.


Applying monopsony to a labour-market context


AQA has tested monopsony directly using the market for social-care workers.


In its November 2020 mark scheme, AQA accepted analysis of government monopsony power when almost all social-care workers were employed in the public sector. The expected model showed low pay and low employment relative to the competitive outcome.


The important exam skill is not memorising one sector.


Instead, identify the economic features of the context:

  • Is there a powerful employer or buyer of labour?

  • Do workers have limited alternatives?

  • Can the employer influence wages?

  • Would a more competitive market produce a different wage and employment outcome?


Monopsony does not mean monopoly


Monopoly concerns seller power.


Monopsony concerns buyer power.


In a labour market:

  • workers supply labour;

  • employers demand, or buy, labour services.


Therefore, an employer with substantial buying power is exercising monopsony power, not monopoly power.


This terminology matters in an A-Level answer.


Monopsony and relative wage rates


AQA requires you to understand that monopsony can reduce the relative wage rate.


Suppose two otherwise similar occupational labour markets exist.


One is competitive and pays:


$$W_c$$


The other is monopsonistic and pays:


$$W_m$$


where:


$$W_m < W_c$$


Monopsony can therefore contribute to wage differences between labour markets.


This develops the competitive analysis studied in Relative wage rates [Relative wage rates].


Monopsony as labour-market imperfection


AQA states that real-world labour markets are imperfectly competitive to varying degrees.


Monopsony is one way in which the competitive model may fail to describe actual wage determination.


Other labour-market imperfections identified by the specification include:

  • trade union power;

  • imperfect information.


These can alter the outcomes generated by straightforward competitive demand and supply.


Effects on workers


In the standard monopsony model, workers experience:

  • a lower wage than under perfect competition;

  • a lower level of employment.


The monopsonist's market power therefore weakens workers' position relative to the competitive benchmark.


AQA mark schemes have linked monopsony power with low pay and low employment.


Effects on the employer


The employer benefits from being able to pay a wage below the competitive wage.


It also chooses a smaller level of employment than would arise under perfect competition.


The model therefore illustrates how buying power can affect factor-market outcomes, just as market power elsewhere in economics can alter price and output.


Moving beyond the basic monopsony model


Lesson 78 establishes the monopsony benchmark.


The next lessons examine forces that can alter this outcome.


In Trade union influence [Trade union influence], you will consider the factors determining trade-union bargaining power.


You will then compare monopsony with worker bargaining power directly in Trade unions and monopsony [Trade unions and monopsony].


The effect of a wage floor in different labour markets is considered later in The National Minimum Wage [The National Minimum Wage].


A reliable method for interpreting a monopsony diagram


Use this order every time:

  1. Identify the MRP curve.

  2. Identify the labour-supply curve.

  3. Identify the MCL curve above labour supply.

  4. Find where:

$$MCL = MRP$$

  1. Trace down to find monopsony employment $$L_m$$.

  2. At $$L_m$$, read across from the labour-supply curve to find wage $$W_m$$.

  3. Find the competitive outcome where:

$$S_L = MRP$$

  1. Label competitive wage $$W_c$$ and employment $$L_c$$.

  2. State explicitly:

$$W_m < W_c$$

and:

$$L_m < L_c$$


That sequence prevents most diagram errors.


Key Words 🔑

Key word

Student-friendly definition

How it may be used in an exam

Monopsony

A market with a single or dominant buyer, giving the buyer significant market power.

Define the source of employer power before analysing wages and employment.

Monopsony power

An employer's ability to influence wages and employment because of its buying power in the labour market.

Explain why outcomes may differ from perfect competition.

Marginal cost of labour (MCL)

The additional labour cost caused by employing an additional unit of labour.

Use the intersection of MCL and MRP to determine monopsony employment.

Marginal revenue product (MRP)

The additional revenue generated by employing an additional unit of labour.

Use as the demand for labour and compare it with MCL.

Competitive wage

The wage determined where market labour demand equals labour supply in the competitive benchmark.

Compare $$W_c$$ with the lower monopsony wage $$W_m$$.


Hints from the Examiner Reports 💡


Examiner hint: Learn the monopsony diagram thoroughly. The November 2020 examiner report found that some students were less familiar with monopsony and its diagram than with other models, which made the related 9-mark question difficult for them.
Examiner hint: Your diagram must be used in the written explanation. In the strongest November 2020 responses, students integrated their diagrams into their analysis. Some weaker responses drew a diagram but never referred to it.
Examiner hint: Compare explicitly with perfect competition. The November 2020 mark scheme expected students to show that both the monopsony wage and monopsony employment were below the perfectly competitive levels.
Examiner hint: Do not read the wage from the MCL and MRP intersection. That point determines the monopsonist's employment level. The wage must then be read from the labour-supply curve at that level of employment.
Examiner hint: More complex labour-market diagrams can score strongly when handled accurately. The June 2022 examiner report noted that some students produced the trade-union and monopsony model perfectly, while inaccurate versions led to confused written analysis.
Examiner hint: In June 2023, stronger responses on monopsony successfully compared wages and employment under monopsony with other labour-market arrangements and used the models to construct logical analytical chains.

Common Mistakes ⚠️


Mistake: Confusing monopsony with monopoly


Why this is incorrect: Monopoly is seller power. Monopsony is buyer power. In a labour market, employers buy labour services.


How to improve: Remember:


monopoly = powerful seller


monopsony = powerful buyer


Mistake: Reading the monopsony wage from MCL = MRP


Why this is incorrect: The MCL and MRP intersection determines the quantity of labour employed, not the wage paid.


How to improve: Find $$L_m$$ where MCL = MRP, then move to the labour-supply curve to find $$W_m$$.


Mistake: Drawing MCL below the labour-supply curve


Why this is incorrect: In the standard monopsony model, the marginal cost of hiring another worker exceeds the wage needed to attract that quantity of labour.


How to improve: Draw MCL above the upward-sloping labour-supply curve.


Mistake: Using the MCL curve as labour demand


Why this is incorrect: Demand for labour is represented by marginal revenue product. MCL represents the additional cost of employing labour.


How to improve: Label:

  • $$MRP = D_L$$;

  • $$S_L = ACL$$;

  • MCL above supply.


Mistake: Saying monopsony increases employment


Why this is incorrect: The standard AQA model predicts that the monopsonist restricts employment below the perfectly competitive level.


How to improve: Always compare:


$$L_m < L_c$$


Mistake: Saying the monopsony wage is higher than the competitive wage


Why this is incorrect: AQA explicitly requires understanding that monopsony power can reduce the relative wage rate below the competitive level.


How to improve: Label both wages clearly and state:


$$W_m < W_c$$


Mistake: Drawing the model without making the competitive comparison


Why this is incorrect: The specification explicitly requires comparison with the wage and employment levels that would exist in a perfectly competitive labour market.


How to improve: Always identify both $$W_m, L_m$$ and $$W_c, L_c$$.


Exam-Style Questions ✍️


Question 1


Define monopsony power in a labour market. [1 mark]


Question 2


Explain why the marginal cost of labour curve lies above the labour-supply curve in the standard monopsony model. [4 marks]


Question 3


State the condition used to determine the level of employment chosen by a monopsonistic employer. [1 mark]


Questions 4 and 5


A monopsonistic employer faces the following simplified labour-market conditions.

Workers employed

Wage required per worker

Marginal cost of labour

Marginal revenue product

1

£20

£20

£100

2

£30

£40

£80

3

£40

£60

£60

4

£50

£80

£50

5

£60

£100

£40


Question 4


Using the data, determine:


a) the number of workers employed by the monopsonist;

b) the wage paid by the monopsonist.

[3 marks]


Question 5


Using the same data, determine the competitive wage and employment level, and compare them with the monopsony outcome. [4 marks]


Question 6


With the help of a diagram, explain how monopsony power may lead to a wage below the competitive labour-market wage. [6 marks]


Question 7


A large employer has considerable market power when recruiting workers in a particular occupational labour market.


With the help of a monopsony diagram, analyse the likely effects of this market power on wages and employment compared with a perfectly competitive labour market. [9 marks]


Question 8


Explain how a monopsonistic employer can use labour-market power to reduce both wages and employment below their perfectly competitive levels. [15 marks]


Answers and mark scheme


Question 1


Award 1 mark for recognising that monopsony power is employer or buyer power that enables an employer to influence wage and employment outcomes in a labour market.


Question 2


Award up to 4 marks for explaining that:

  • the labour-supply curve shows the wage required to attract different quantities of labour;

  • additional workers can require a higher wage;

  • in the standard model, the higher wage is paid to the existing workforce as well;

  • therefore the additional cost of increasing employment is greater than the wage itself, so MCL lies above labour supply.


Question 3


Award 1 mark for:


$$MCL = MRP$$


Question 4


At three workers:


$$MCL = £60$$


and:


$$MRP = £60$$


Therefore:


$$L_m = 3$$


At three workers, the wage required on the labour-supply schedule is:


$$W_m = £40$$


Award:

  • 1 mark for identifying three workers;

  • 1 mark for using MCL = MRP;

  • 1 mark for identifying the £40 wage.


Maximum: 3 marks.


Question 5


Under competition, the wage equals MRP at four workers:


$$W_c = £50$$


$$MRP = £50$$


Therefore:


$$L_c = 4$$


Comparing the outcomes:


$$W_m = £40 < £50 = W_c$$


and:


$$L_m = 3 < 4 = L_c$$


Award up to 4 marks for:

  • competitive wage of £50;

  • competitive employment of four workers;

  • correct comparison of wages;

  • correct comparison of employment.


Question 6


Award up to 6 marks.


Indicative content:

  • correctly labelled upward-sloping labour-supply curve;

  • MCL curve above labour supply;

  • downward-sloping MRP curve;

  • monopsony employment determined where MCL = MRP;

  • wage read from the supply curve at the monopsony employment level;

  • comparison showing $$W_m < W_c$$.


A strong answer should also identify the competitive wage where labour supply intersects MRP.


Question 7


Use the level descriptors below.


Level 3, 7–9 marks: A clear and accurately labelled monopsony diagram is integrated into the analysis. The answer explains employer buying power, determines monopsony employment using MCL = MRP, obtains the wage from the labour-supply curve and compares this with the competitive equilibrium where supply intersects MRP. It clearly establishes that monopsony produces both a lower wage and lower employment.


Level 2, 4–6 marks: Reasonable understanding of monopsony with a relevant diagram. The answer recognises lower wages and/or employment, but the determination of the outcome or competitive comparison may be underdeveloped.


Level 1, 1–3 marks: Limited relevant understanding. The response may define monopsony or state that wages are lower but provides little accurate diagrammatic or analytical development.


0 marks: No relevant economic content.


Question 8


Use the level descriptors below.


Indicative content may include:

  • definition of monopsony;

  • explanation of monopsony power as employer buying power;

  • monopsony as an imperfection in the labour market;

  • upward-sloping labour-supply curve;

  • supply curve as the wage required to attract different quantities of labour;

  • marginal cost of labour;

  • explanation of why MCL lies above labour supply;

  • marginal revenue product as labour demand;

  • monopsony employment where:

$$MCL = MRP$$

  • monopsony wage read from the labour-supply curve;

  • competitive equilibrium where:

$$S_L = MRP$$

  • comparison of monopsony and competitive wages;

  • comparison of monopsony and competitive employment;

  • recognition that:

$$W_m < W_c$$

and:

$$L_m < L_c$$

  • explanation that the monopsony wage may be below the MRP of labour;

  • application to an appropriate labour-market context;

  • accurate and integrated diagrammatic analysis.


Level 3, 11–15 marks: A well-organised response demonstrating sound understanding of monopsony power and the monopsony labour-market model. The MCL, labour-supply and MRP curves are accurately explained, the monopsony wage and employment are correctly determined, and the answer develops a clear comparison with perfect competition. Diagrammatic analysis forms part of a logical chain showing why both wages and employment are lower.


Level 2, 6–10 marks: Reasonable understanding of monopsony and its effects. A relevant diagram may be used, but parts of the model, such as the distinction between MCL and the wage or the comparison with the competitive outcome, may be incomplete.


Level 1, 1–5 marks: Limited knowledge of monopsony. The response may recognise employer market power and lower wages but contains little developed analysis or significant diagrammatic confusion.


0 marks: No relevant economic content.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Relative wage rates | AQA A-Level Economics

For Specification 7136 AQA A-Level Economics | Free Revision Notes Estimated study time: 40–50 minutes Relative wage rates A-Level Economics revision explains why workers in different occupations can

 
 
 
Changes in labour supply | AQA A-Level Economics

For Specification 7136 AQA A-Level Economics | Free Revision Notes Estimated study time: 40–50 minutes Changes in labour supply A-Level Economics revision focuses on why the number of workers willing

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page