Perfectly competitive labour markets | AQA A-Level Economics
For Specification 7136
AQA A-Level Economics | Free Revision Notes
Estimated study time: 40–50 minutes
Perfectly competitive labour markets A-Level Economics revision brings labour demand and labour supply together to explain how market forces determine wages and employment. For AQA 7136, you need to understand the economists' model of wage determination in a perfectly competitive labour market and use labour-market diagrams accurately. This builds directly on labour demand [The demand for labour] and occupational labour supply [The supply of labour to occupations], and provides the benchmark needed for analysing relative wage rates [Relative wage rates] and imperfect labour markets.
Learning Objectives 🎯
By the end of this revision page, you should be able to:
Explain how demand and supply determine wages in a perfectly competitive labour market.
Construct a correctly labelled labour demand and supply diagram.
Identify the equilibrium wage rate and equilibrium level of employment.
Explain how labour shortages and surpluses create wage adjustments.
Determine equilibrium wages and employment from diagrams and data.
Apply the competitive labour-market model to unfamiliar occupational contexts.
Revision Notes 📚
Perfectly competitive labour markets: A-Level Economics revision essentials
AQA requires students to understand the economists' model of wage determination in a perfectly competitive labour market. The specification also makes clear that perfect competition acts as a useful benchmark, while real-world labour markets are imperfectly competitive to a greater or lesser extent.
The model brings together two ideas you have already studied:
demand for labour, representing employers;
supply of labour, representing workers.
Their interaction determines:
the equilibrium wage rate;
the equilibrium level of employment.
The demand for labour
The labour-demand curve slopes downwards.
Wage rate
|
|\
| \
| \
| \
| \ D_L
| \
+---------------- LabourIt shows the relationship between the wage rate and the number of workers employers wish to employ.
At a lower wage rate, a greater quantity of labour is demanded, other things being equal.
The reasoning comes from marginal productivity theory [The demand for labour]. Firms compare the additional revenue generated by workers with the cost of employing them.
The supply of labour
The market labour-supply curve normally slopes upwards.
Wage rate
|
| / S_L
| /
| /
| /
| /
| /
+---------------- LabourIt shows the relationship between the wage rate and the number of workers willing to work in an occupation.
A higher wage rate makes an occupation more financially attractive, so more workers are normally willing to supply their labour.
You studied the influences on this curve in The supply of labour to occupations [The supply of labour to occupations].
Bringing labour demand and labour supply together
In a competitive labour market, the equilibrium wage is determined where labour demand and labour supply intersect.
Wage rate
|
| S_L
| /
W* |-----E
| / \
| / \
| / \ D_L
| /
+---------------- Labour
L*At point $$E$$:
$$L_D = L_S$$
where:
$$L_D$$ = quantity of labour demanded;
$$L_S$$ = quantity of labour supplied.
The equilibrium wage is $$W^*$$.
The equilibrium level of employment is $$L^*$$.
The equilibrium wage rate
The equilibrium wage rate is the wage at which the quantity of labour employers wish to hire is equal to the quantity of labour workers are willing to supply.
At this wage:
employers can hire the quantity of labour they want;
the number of workers willing to work matches employers' demand;
there is neither excess demand nor excess supply of labour.
The wage therefore performs the same coordinating role as price in an ordinary product market.
The equilibrium level of employment
The equilibrium level of employment is the quantity of labour employed at the equilibrium wage.
It is found by tracing from the intersection of the demand and supply curves down to the horizontal axis.
Do not confuse:
equilibrium wage, measured on the vertical axis;
equilibrium employment, measured on the horizontal axis.
Determining equilibrium from a schedule
Suppose a labour market has the following demand and supply conditions.
Weekly wage | Workers demanded | Workers supplied |
£400 | 1,800 | 800 |
£500 | 1,600 | 1,100 |
£600 | 1,400 | 1,400 |
£700 | 1,200 | 1,700 |
£800 | 1,000 | 2,000 |
Equilibrium occurs at £600 per week, because:
$$L_D = L_S = 1,400$$
Therefore:
$$\text{Equilibrium wage} = £600$$
and:
$$\text{Equilibrium employment} = 1,400 \text{ workers}$$
What happens below the equilibrium wage?
Suppose the wage is only £500.
From the table:
$$L_D = 1,600$$
and:
$$L_S = 1,100$$
There is therefore a shortage of:
$$1,600 - 1,100 = 500 \text{ workers}$$
This is excess demand for labour.
Wage rate
|
| S_L
W* |------E
| / \
W1 |----A---\-----------B
| / \ D_L
| /
+----------------------- Labour
L_S L_D
<--- shortage --->At wage $$W_1$$:
$$L_D > L_S$$
Employers want to employ more workers than are willing to work.
How a labour shortage affects wages
A shortage places upward pressure on wages.
The adjustment can be explained step by step:
At the existing wage, employers cannot recruit all the workers they want.
Firms compete for the available workers.
Employers have an incentive to offer higher wages.
Higher wages encourage more workers to supply labour.
Higher wages also reduce the quantity of labour demanded.
The shortage becomes smaller.
Wages continue adjusting until labour demand equals labour supply.
The market therefore moves towards equilibrium.
AQA's June 2024 mark scheme explicitly identified the role of employer competition, upward pressure on wages and adjustment until labour demand and labour supply return to equilibrium.
Wage adjustment from a shortage
Using the earlier table, at £500:
labour demanded = 1,600 workers;
labour supplied = 1,100 workers.
As the wage rises towards £600:
some employers reduce the number of workers they want;
more workers are willing to work.
At £600:
$$L_D = L_S = 1,400$$
The shortage has disappeared.
What happens above the equilibrium wage?
Now suppose the wage is £700.
From the table:
$$L_D = 1,200$$
and:
$$L_S = 1,700$$
There is excess supply of:
$$1,700 - 1,200 = 500 \text{ workers}$$
This is an excess supply of labour, sometimes described as a labour surplus.
Wage rate
|
W2 |----A-----------B
| \ /
W* |------\---E---/
| \ / S_L
| \
| \ D_L
+----------------------- Labour
L_D L_S
<--- surplus --->At wage $$W_2$$:
$$L_S > L_D$$
More workers are willing to work than employers want to hire.
How excess labour supply affects wages
Excess supply creates downward pressure on wages.
The adjustment process is:
More workers want jobs than employers wish to offer.
There is competition among workers for available employment.
The wage is under downward pressure.
A lower wage increases the quantity of labour demanded.
A lower wage reduces the quantity of labour supplied.
The surplus becomes smaller.
Equilibrium is restored when labour demand equals labour supply.
Again:
$$L_D = L_S$$
at the equilibrium wage.
The market mechanism in labour markets
The competitive labour-market model applies the familiar market mechanism to labour.
Situation | Relationship | Pressure on wage | Market response |
Below equilibrium wage | $$L_D > L_S$$ | Upward | Wage rises |
At equilibrium wage | $$L_D = L_S$$ | None | Market is in equilibrium |
Above equilibrium wage | $$L_S > L_D$$ | Downward | Wage falls |
This is the same fundamental adjustment mechanism studied in market equilibrium and disequilibrium [Market equilibrium and disequilibrium], but applied to a factor market.
Why rising wages help eliminate a shortage
A rising wage affects both sides of the labour market.
Effect on labour supply
A higher wage increases the financial reward from working in the occupation.
Therefore:
Wage rises → quantity of labour supplied increases.
This is an extension along the supply curve.
Effect on labour demand
A higher wage raises the cost of employing labour.
Therefore:
Wage rises → quantity of labour demanded falls.
This is a contraction along the demand curve.
These two adjustments move the labour market towards equilibrium.
Why falling wages help eliminate excess supply
A falling wage also affects both sides.
Effect on labour supply
Wage falls → occupation becomes less financially attractive → quantity of labour supplied falls.
Effect on labour demand
Wage falls → labour becomes less costly to employ → quantity of labour demanded rises.
The gap between labour supply and labour demand therefore narrows until equilibrium is restored.
Changes in equilibrium
Equilibrium is not permanently fixed.
Changes in labour demand or labour supply can create a new equilibrium.
You studied the causes of these shifts in Changes in the demand for labour [Changes in the demand for labour] and Changes in labour supply [Changes in labour supply].
Increase in labour demand
Suppose demand for labour increases from $$D_1$$ to $$D_2$$ while labour supply remains unchanged.
Wage rate
|
| S_L
W2 |-------E2
| / \
W1 |----E1 \ D2
| / \ \
| / \ D1
+---------------- Labour
L1 L2The likely outcome is:
$$W_2 > W_1$$
and:
$$L_2 > L_1$$
So an increase in labour demand raises both:
the equilibrium wage;
the equilibrium level of employment.
At the original wage, the increase in demand creates excess demand for labour. Employers compete for workers, placing upward pressure on wages until the new equilibrium is reached.
Decrease in labour demand
A decrease in labour demand shifts the demand curve to the left.
With supply unchanged, the likely outcome is:
a lower equilibrium wage;
a lower equilibrium level of employment.
At the original wage, there is excess supply of workers, placing downward pressure on wages.
Increase in labour supply
Suppose labour supply shifts right from $$S_1$$ to $$S_2$$.
Wage rate
|
| S1
W1 |----E1
| / \
W2 |--/----E2
| / S2 \
|/ / \ D_L
+---------------- Labour
L1 L2The likely result is:
$$W_2 < W_1$$
and:
$$L_2 > L_1$$
So an increase in labour supply tends to:
reduce the equilibrium wage;
increase equilibrium employment.
Decrease in labour supply
If labour supply shifts left:
the equilibrium wage tends to rise;
equilibrium employment tends to fall.
At the original wage there will be a shortage of labour.
This creates upward pressure on wages as employers compete for a smaller number of available workers.
Be precise about shortages
A shortage does not itself shift the labour-supply curve.
The correct sequence might be:
Labour supply decreases → supply curve shifts left → shortage exists at the original wage → wage rises → new equilibrium is reached.
The June 2024 examiner report highlighted that many students reversed this chain and incorrectly claimed that a shortage caused supply to shift left.
The role of wages as market signals
Changes in wages help communicate information within the labour market.
A rising wage indicates that labour is relatively scarce compared with employers' demand.
This can:
encourage more workers to enter the occupation;
encourage employers to reduce the amount of labour demanded.
A falling wage indicates that labour is relatively abundant compared with employer demand.
AQA's 2024 mark scheme recognised the signalling, incentive and rationing roles of wage changes in the competitive labour-market adjustment process.
A competitive labour market as a benchmark
The perfectly competitive labour-market model is an economic model.
AQA explicitly states that students should appreciate that all real-world markets are imperfectly competitive to a greater or lesser extent.
This means you should not normally claim that a real occupation is literally a perfectly competitive labour market.
Instead, use the model as a benchmark for analysing how market forces would determine wages and employment when competitive forces operate.
This becomes especially important when comparing the model with monopsony power [Monopsony in the labour market], trade unions and other labour-market imperfections later in the course.
Perfect competition and earlier market-structure learning
AQA also describes perfect competition as a useful yardstick for judging real-world markets, including labour markets.
In the labour-market model, the key focus is not the firm's product-market cost and revenue curves. Instead, it is the interaction between:
market demand for labour;
market supply of labour;
the wage rate;
employment.
Do not accidentally reproduce the firm's perfect-competition product-market diagram when asked about a labour market.
Determining equilibrium from numerical data
Consider another market.
Hourly wage | Labour demanded | Labour supplied |
£12 | 2,400 | 1,200 |
£14 | 2,100 | 1,500 |
£16 | 1,800 | 1,800 |
£18 | 1,500 | 2,100 |
£20 | 1,200 | 2,400 |
At £16:
$$L_D = 1,800$$
and:
$$L_S = 1,800$$
Therefore:
$$\text{Equilibrium wage} = £16 \text{ per hour}$$
$$\text{Equilibrium employment} = 1,800 \text{ workers}$$
At £14:
$$\text{Shortage} = 2,100 - 1,500$$
$$\text{Shortage} = 600 \text{ workers}$$
At £18:
$$\text{Excess supply} = 2,100 - 1,500$$
$$\text{Excess supply} = 600 \text{ workers}$$
Always check carefully which figure is labour demanded and which is labour supplied.
Applying the model to occupations
Suppose demand for a particular service rises.
Because labour demand is derived:
Demand for service rises → derived demand for relevant workers rises → labour demand shifts right → shortage at original wage → upward pressure on wages → employment rises → new equilibrium.
Alternatively, suppose the number of suitably qualified workers increases:
Labour supply rises → supply shifts right → excess labour supply at original wage → downward pressure on wages → employment rises → new equilibrium.
The model therefore provides a framework for explaining changes in many different occupational labour markets.
From equilibrium wages to wage differences
Different occupations can have different labour-demand and labour-supply conditions.
Consequently, their equilibrium wage rates may differ.
For example, one occupation may have:
stronger demand for labour;
more restricted labour supply.
Another may have:
weaker demand;
a larger supply of workers.
The resulting equilibrium wages will differ.
This is the focus of relative wage rates [Relative wage rates].
From perfect competition to imperfect labour markets
A competitive equilibrium is also the benchmark against which AQA asks you to compare imperfect labour markets.
For example, in monopsony [Monopsony in the labour market], employer market power can produce both a lower wage and lower employment than would exist in the competitive outcome.
Later lessons will also examine how trade unions and minimum wages can alter the wage and employment outcomes shown by the basic competitive model.
Key Words 🔑
Key word | Student-friendly definition | How it may be used in an exam |
Equilibrium wage rate | The wage at which the quantity of labour demanded equals the quantity of labour supplied. | Identify the wage at the intersection of labour demand and supply. |
Equilibrium employment | The quantity of labour employed when labour demand equals labour supply. | Read the employment level from the horizontal axis at equilibrium. |
Labour shortage | A situation where employers demand more labour than workers supply at the current wage. | Explain upward pressure on wages in a competitive labour market. |
Excess supply of labour | A situation where more labour is supplied than employers demand at the current wage. | Explain downward pressure on wages and movement towards equilibrium. |
Competitive labour market | A labour-market model in which market forces of demand and supply determine the wage and employment outcome. | Use as the benchmark when analysing wage determination and comparing imperfect labour markets. |
Hints from the Examiner Reports 💡
Examiner hint: Show the shortage, not just a curve shift. In the June 2024 examination, very few students clearly identified the excess demand for labour created at the original wage. AQA expected the diagram and written explanation to show why the market was initially out of equilibrium.
Examiner hint: Explain the adjustment process all the way to the new equilibrium. The strongest 2024 responses analysed how wages changed after the initial shortage and how labour supply and demand adjusted until equilibrium was restored.
Examiner hint: Keep cause and effect in the correct order. A common 2024 error was to claim that a labour shortage caused the supply curve to shift left. Instead, a fall in labour supply can shift the curve left, creating a shortage at the original wage.
Examiner hint: Integrate your diagram into the written answer. AQA's 9-mark level descriptors reward an accurate diagram most effectively when it is used to develop a clear and logical chain of reasoning rather than simply being drawn beside the response.
Examiner hint: Be clear about which side of the labour market you are discussing. Examiner reports have identified confusion between demand for labour and supply of labour as a source of weak analysis. Employers demand labour, workers supply it.
Examiner hint: Treat perfect competition as a model rather than assuming that actual occupations exactly match it. AQA requires students to recognise that real-world labour markets are imperfectly competitive to some degree.
Common Mistakes ⚠️
Mistake: Reversing the labour-demand and labour-supply curves
Why this is incorrect: Labour demand slopes downwards while market labour supply normally slopes upwards.
How to improve: Remember who is making the decision:
employers demand labour;
workers supply labour.
Mistake: Putting employment on the vertical axis
Why this is incorrect: The standard labour-market diagram places the wage rate on the vertical axis and the quantity of labour or employment on the horizontal axis.
How to improve: Label your axes before drawing either curve.
Mistake: Identifying the equilibrium wage but not equilibrium employment
Why this is incorrect: AQA's labour-market model determines both wages and employment.
How to improve: From the intersection of supply and demand, trace horizontally to find the wage and vertically downwards to find employment.
Mistake: Saying any wage is an equilibrium wage
Why this is incorrect: Equilibrium only occurs where:
$$L_D = L_S$$
How to improve: Compare the quantities demanded and supplied before deciding whether the market is in equilibrium.
Mistake: Saying a shortage lowers wages
Why this is incorrect: A shortage means employers want more labour than is available at the current wage. Competition among employers creates upward pressure on wages.
How to improve: Use the chain:
shortage → employers compete for workers → wage rises.
Mistake: Saying excess labour supply raises wages
Why this is incorrect: When more workers want jobs than employers wish to offer, there is downward pressure on wages.
How to improve: Use:
excess supply → competition for jobs → downward wage pressure.
Mistake: Saying a shortage shifts labour supply
Why this is incorrect: A shortage describes disequilibrium at a particular wage. It does not itself change a determinant of labour supply.
How to improve: Identify the original cause first, such as a fall in labour supply or rise in labour demand, then explain the shortage created at the old wage.
Mistake: Drawing the product-market perfect competition diagram
Why this is incorrect: This lesson concerns the labour market, so you need labour demand and labour supply, not a firm's AR, MR, MC and AC curves.
How to improve: Check the axes. A labour-market diagram must show wage rate and labour or employment.
Exam-Style Questions ✍️
Question 1
Define the equilibrium wage rate in a competitive labour market. [1 mark]
Question 2
State what is meant by the equilibrium level of employment. [2 marks]
Questions 3, 4 and 5
The table shows demand and supply in a hypothetical competitive labour market.
Weekly wage | Workers demanded | Workers supplied |
£450 | 2,200 | 1,000 |
£500 | 2,000 | 1,300 |
£550 | 1,800 | 1,600 |
£600 | 1,600 | 1,600 |
£650 | 1,400 | 1,900 |
£700 | 1,200 | 2,200 |
Question 3
Identify the equilibrium wage and equilibrium level of employment. [2 marks]
Question 4
Calculate the shortage of labour if the wage rate is £500 per week. [2 marks]
Question 5
Calculate the excess supply of labour if the wage rate is £650 per week. [2 marks]
Question 6
With the help of a diagram, explain how wages are determined in a perfectly competitive labour market. [6 marks]
Question 7
A labour market is initially in equilibrium. Demand for workers then increases while labour supply remains unchanged.
Analyse the likely effects on the equilibrium wage rate and employment. [6 marks]
Question 8
A particular occupation is experiencing a shortage of 4,000 workers at its current wage rate.
With the help of a diagram, explain how market forces may remove this shortage in a competitive labour market. [9 marks]
Question 9
Explain how the interaction of labour demand and labour supply determines wages and employment in a perfectly competitive labour market. [15 marks]
Answers and mark scheme
Question 1
Award 1 mark for recognising that the equilibrium wage is the wage rate at which the quantity of labour demanded equals the quantity of labour supplied.
Question 2
Award up to 2 marks for explaining that:
it is the quantity of labour at the market equilibrium;
at this employment level, the quantity of labour supplied equals the quantity demanded.
Question 3
At £600:
$$L_D = L_S = 1,600$$
Therefore:
Equilibrium wage = £600 per week.Equilibrium employment = 1,600 workers.
Award 1 mark for each correct answer.
Question 4
At £500:
$$L_D = 2,000$$
$$L_S = 1,300$$
Therefore:
$$\text{Shortage} = 2,000 - 1,300$$
$$\text{Shortage} = 700 \text{ workers}$$
Award:
1 mark for the correct method;
1 mark for 700 workers.
Question 5
At £650:
$$L_S = 1,900$$
$$L_D = 1,400$$
Therefore:
$$\text{Excess supply} = 1,900 - 1,400$$
$$\text{Excess supply} = 500 \text{ workers}$$
Award:
1 mark for the correct method;
1 mark for 500 workers.
Question 6
Award up to 6 marks.
Indicative content:
wage rate correctly placed on the vertical axis;
labour or employment on the horizontal axis;
downward-sloping labour-demand curve;
upward-sloping labour-supply curve;
equilibrium identified at the intersection;
explanation that the equilibrium wage is where quantity demanded equals quantity supplied;
explanation that equilibrium employment is determined at the same intersection.
A strong response should use the diagram as part of the explanation rather than drawing it without reference.
Question 7
Award up to 6 marks.
Indicative chain:
demand for labour shifts right;
at the original wage, labour demanded exceeds labour supplied;
a shortage of labour develops;
employers compete for workers;
wages rise;
higher wages encourage an extension in labour supply and contraction in labour demand;
a new equilibrium is established;
the new equilibrium has a higher wage and higher employment.
A relevant diagram should show a rightward shift from $$D_1$$ to $$D_2$$ with labour supply unchanged.
Question 8
Use the level descriptors below.
Level 3, 7–9 marks: A clear and accurate labour-market diagram is used to show excess demand at the original wage. The answer explains that employers compete for scarce workers, placing upward pressure on wages. The higher wage causes an extension in labour supply and a contraction in labour demand until the shortage disappears and a new equilibrium is reached. Analysis is clear and logically developed.
Level 2, 4–6 marks: Reasonable understanding of a labour shortage and wage adjustment. A relevant diagram may be present, but the movement towards equilibrium is not fully developed or contains some confusion.
Level 1, 1–3 marks: Limited relevant knowledge. The response may state that wages rise but gives little explanation of the adjustment process or contains significant diagrammatic errors.
0 marks: No relevant economic content.
Question 9
Use the level descriptors below.
Indicative content may include:
definition of a competitive labour market;
demand for labour;
supply of labour;
downward-sloping labour-demand curve;
upward-sloping market labour-supply curve;
equilibrium wage rate;
equilibrium level of employment;
condition $$L_D = L_S$$;
shortage or excess demand below equilibrium;
upward pressure on wages;
effects of rising wages on labour demanded and supplied;
excess supply above equilibrium;
downward pressure on wages;
adjustment towards equilibrium;
changes in equilibrium following shifts in demand or supply;
relevant labour-market diagrams;
recognition that perfect competition is an economic benchmark and that real labour markets are imperfectly competitive to some degree.
Level 3, 11–15 marks: A well-organised response showing sound knowledge of wage determination in a competitive labour market. Demand and supply are accurately explained, the equilibrium wage and employment level are identified, and disequilibrium is analysed through clear chains showing how wages adjust. Relevant diagrams are accurately constructed and effectively integrated.
Level 2, 6–10 marks: Reasonable understanding of labour demand, labour supply and equilibrium, but some explanation may be underdeveloped. The adjustment process may be incomplete or diagrams may contain minor errors.
Level 1, 1–5 marks: Limited relevant understanding. The response may recognise that wages are determined by demand and supply but provides little developed analysis, or may confuse labour demand with labour supply.
0 marks: No relevant economic content.

Comments