Race, Ethnicity and Prejudice | The Great Gatsby
A-Level English Literature | Free Revision Notes
Estimated study time: 45 minutes
Race, ethnicity and prejudice form an uncomfortable but important part of The Great Gatsby. Fitzgerald places Tom Buchanan's openly racist ideas within a society experiencing rapid social and cultural change, while the novel also contains racial and ethnic stereotypes that modern readers need to examine critically. These Race, Ethnicity and Prejudice A-Level English Revision notes explore Tom's fears about changing American identity, contemporary anxieties surrounding immigration and the ways prejudice intersects with class and power. This theme is especially relevant to Tom's attitudes towards social change [Tom Buchanan].
Learning Objectives 🎯
By the end of this revision page, you should be able to:
Analyse Tom's racial anxieties and explain how they connect with his wider fear of losing social dominance.
Explain how contemporary debates about immigration, race and American identity illuminate the novel.
Evaluate Fitzgerald's presentation of racial and ethnic stereotypes without assuming that every attitude expressed by a character represents the author's own view.
Analyse how prejudice contributes to the novel's wider concern with social hierarchy, exclusion and resistance to change.
Revision Notes 📚
Race, Ethnicity and Prejudice A-Level English Revision: Approaching the Topic
Race and ethnicity require particularly careful analysis in The Great Gatsby.
The novel contains prejudiced attitudes and racialised descriptions that reflect aspects of its historical setting but may be offensive to modern readers.
A strong A-Level response should therefore distinguish between:
a character expressing prejudice
the narrator's language
Fitzgerald's wider presentation of prejudice
the assumptions of the society represented
a modern reader's critical response
These categories are not always identical.
📌 Exam focus: Avoid writing that "Fitzgerald is racist because Tom is racist" or that "Fitzgerald condemns all racism because Tom is unpleasant". Literary representation is more complicated. Analyse who expresses an attitude, how the novel presents that character and whether the text itself reproduces stereotypes elsewhere.
Tom Buchanan's Racial Anxieties
Tom expresses explicitly racist ideas early in the novel.
He is anxious about the supposed decline of white social dominance and refers approvingly to pseudo-intellectual arguments that divide people into racial hierarchies.
His thinking is based on the false belief that racial groups can be ranked biologically and that white Americans face displacement by supposedly inferior groups.
These beliefs are important because they reveal far more than prejudice alone.
Tom is deeply concerned with maintaining hierarchy.
He wants established distinctions between:
white and non-white
rich and poor
old money and new money
men and women
socially established people and outsiders
His racism therefore forms part of a much broader desire to preserve his own position at the top of several social hierarchies.
Race and Tom's Need for Superiority
Tom's identity depends heavily upon dominance.
He possesses:
inherited wealth
social status
physical strength
male privilege
membership of an established elite
His racial attitudes reinforce the belief that hierarchy is natural.
Rather than seeing social position as historically produced or changeable, Tom tends to treat existing inequalities as justified.
This makes his racism closely connected with his performance of masculine and social dominance [Gender, Masculinity and Femininity].
Tom is not merely afraid of racial change.
He appears afraid of any development that threatens a world in which people like him automatically occupy the highest position.
Tom and Fear of Social Change
Tom's prejudice can therefore be understood partly as status anxiety.
Status anxiety is fear about losing one's social position, authority or superiority.
Tom is materially secure, yet repeatedly behaves as though his world is under threat.
He feels challenged by:
Gatsby's economic rise
Daisy's relationship with Gatsby
changing gender expectations
social mobility
changing ideas about race and American identity
These anxieties overlap.
The same character who objects to Gatsby entering his social world also fears broader changes to racial hierarchy.
💡 Strong interpretation: Tom's racism helps establish him as a defender of inherited hierarchy. He wants social boundaries to remain fixed because those boundaries guarantee his own superiority.
Race and Class Hierarchy
The novel repeatedly presents American society as divided into groups.
Class hierarchy is especially visible through East Egg, West Egg and the valley of ashes.
Tom's racial thinking extends the same logic of hierarchy into race.
He assumes that society should contain clearly defined groups and that some groups should remain above others.
This creates an important connection with Fitzgerald's presentation of class and inherited privilege [Wealth, Class and Social Status].
Tom's worldview depends upon exclusion.
The precise boundary changes according to the situation, but the principle remains similar:
people who already possess power should retain it.
Historical Context: Race and American Identity
The novel was published in 1925 and reflects a period when debates about race, immigration and national identity were particularly visible in the United States.
Ideas about who counted as properly "American" were often connected with:
race
ancestry
immigration
religion
language
social class
Some Americans responded to demographic and cultural change through nativism, the belief that the interests and identity of established native-born inhabitants should be protected against immigrants or newer groups.
Such thinking frequently overlapped with racial and ethnic prejudice.
This context helps explain why Tom treats demographic change as a threat to the social order.
Nativism
Nativism involves hostility towards immigration or the belief that established inhabitants possess a stronger claim to national identity than newcomers.
Nativist attitudes existed long before the 1920s, but they became especially visible during the period surrounding the novel.
Concerns focused particularly upon immigrants who did not fit older ideas of white Anglo-American identity.
These fears could involve prejudice relating to:
nationality
religion
language
ethnicity
race
Tom's racial anxiety therefore belongs within a wider culture in which some Americans worried that traditional definitions of national identity were changing.
Immigration and the 1920s
The United States experienced significant immigration during the decades before the novel's publication.
By the 1920s, political pressure had grown to restrict immigration.
Immigrants from southern and eastern Europe were often treated with suspicion by nativists, while Asian immigration faced particularly severe racial restrictions.
These debates matter when studying The Great Gatsby because the novel repeatedly asks:
Who belongs in America?
That question operates through race, ethnicity and class.
Gatsby himself is not presented as a racial outsider, but he experiences another form of exclusion because established elites do not consider money alone sufficient to make him one of them.
Race and the Idea of "True" American Identity
Tom's racial attitudes assume that American identity belongs more naturally to some people than others.
This is significant because The Great Gatsby is deeply interested in the meaning of America.
Gatsby represents one version of American identity:
self-invention
ambition
mobility
transformation
Tom represents another:
inheritance
established hierarchy
exclusion
preservation of existing privilege
The conflict between them therefore has implications beyond their rivalry over Daisy.
Tom's worldview suggests that identity should be inherited and protected.
Gatsby's existence suggests that identity can be created.
This connects prejudice directly with Gatsby's belief in self-creation and opportunity [Identity and Self-Creation].
American Identity as Inclusive or Exclusive
The American Dream appears to promise that individuals can improve their circumstances regardless of origin.
However, prejudice creates boundaries around that promise.
If race, ethnicity, ancestry or inherited status determine who is considered fully entitled to opportunity, then the ideal of universal mobility becomes limited.
The novel can therefore be read as exposing tensions between:
an America that promises individual possibility
and
an America structured by exclusion and hierarchy.
This makes race and ethnicity relevant to the contradictions within the American Dream [The American Dream].
Pseudo-Scientific Racism
Tom attempts to present his racist beliefs as though they are supported by intellectual authority.
This reflects the circulation of pseudo-scientific racism, false theories that attempted to give racial prejudice the appearance of scientific legitimacy.
Such ideas tried to divide human beings into supposedly distinct biological races and rank those groups according to invented hierarchies.
These theories are not scientifically valid.
Their importance to the novel lies in how Tom uses them.
He does not present prejudice simply as personal dislike.
He attempts to make inequality appear rational and natural.
Why Tom Uses Supposed Intellectual Authority
Tom's reliance on a supposedly authoritative book reveals something about his character.
He wants his existing prejudices confirmed.
This suggests confirmation bias, the tendency to accept information that supports beliefs already held.
Tom's behaviour can therefore be interpreted as intellectually insecure.
He presents himself as knowledgeable, yet his argument relies upon crude generalisation and prejudice.
Fitzgerald places racist ideology in the mouth of a character already associated with arrogance, violence and entitlement.
This context encourages readers to scrutinise rather than automatically accept Tom's claims.
Tom's Contradictions
Tom presents himself as defending civilisation and social order.
Yet his own behaviour includes:
infidelity
violence
dishonesty
manipulation
irresponsibility
This creates an important irony.
The character most concerned with defending supposed social superiority often behaves in ways that undermine any claim to moral superiority.
📚 Exam advice: This contradiction can support an argument that Tom's prejudice is less about protecting civilisation than protecting privilege.
Prejudice and Entitlement
Prejudice helps Tom justify unequal treatment.
If some groups are naturally superior, then unequal power can appear deserved.
This logic supports his wider sense of entitlement.
Tom repeatedly behaves as though:
his wealth makes his authority natural
his social group deserves superiority
his masculinity gives him control
outsiders threaten a legitimate hierarchy
Racial prejudice is therefore one part of a larger ideology of dominance.
Social Change in the 1920s
The social world of the novel is characterised by rapid change.
Relevant developments include:
new forms of wealth
expanding consumer culture
migration
changing urban life
changing expectations of women
debates about immigration
new forms of popular culture
For some characters, change creates possibility.
For Tom, change frequently creates anxiety.
Understanding the social transformations of the period [America in the 1920s] therefore helps explain why he is so defensive.
Race and the Modern City
New York represents movement, diversity and modernity within the novel.
Characters move between different social and ethnic environments.
The city contains a wider variety of people than the exclusive world of East Egg.
This makes the urban environment important when considering American identity.
Tom's desire for stable hierarchy exists within a modern society in which old boundaries appear increasingly difficult to maintain.
Black Americans in the Novel
Black characters occupy only very limited space in The Great Gatsby.
They do not receive the developed interior lives given to Gatsby, Nick, Daisy or Tom.
This is significant.
A modern reader can observe that a novel concerned with American identity largely centres wealthy white experience.
Black Americans appear mainly in brief descriptions rather than as major speaking characters.
This limitation should be acknowledged rather than ignored.
A Brief Racialised Scene in New York
At one point, Nick observes affluent Black passengers travelling through the city.
The moment is brief but significant.
It suggests a social world in which some traditional expectations about race and status are being disrupted.
Nick reacts to the scene as part of the strangeness and possibility of the modern city.
However, the language used to describe the passengers is racialised and reflects stereotypes that modern readers should approach critically.
The episode can therefore be read in two directions:
it hints at changing racial and social possibilities
it also demonstrates the racial assumptions embedded within the novel's language
Both elements matter.
Race and Social Mobility
The sight of affluent Black Americans is particularly relevant because the novel repeatedly connects wealth with social mobility.
If people historically excluded from elite status can acquire visible signs of prosperity, older social assumptions become less secure.
For a character such as Tom, this kind of change threatens the idea that social position should follow inherited racial and class hierarchies.
The scene therefore contributes to the novel's wider interest in old money, new money and changing social boundaries [Old Money, New Money and Social Mobility].
Fitzgerald and Racial Stereotypes
It is important to distinguish Tom's explicit racism from racial stereotypes that appear elsewhere in the novel.
The text sometimes uses descriptions of race and ethnicity that modern readers may recognise as stereotyped or offensive.
This complicates any argument that Fitzgerald simply exposes prejudice from a detached or fully critical position.
A sophisticated interpretation might argue that the novel:
presents Tom's racism critically
records contemporary anxieties about social change
yet also participates at times in racial and ethnic stereotypes common within its historical environment
These ideas can coexist.
Author, Narrator and Character
When analysing offensive attitudes, keep three levels separate.
Character
A character may express prejudiced views.
Tom is the clearest example.
Narrator
Nick's descriptive language may itself contain assumptions shaped by his period and social environment.
Author
Fitzgerald constructs the entire text, but determining his personal beliefs from individual sentences is much more complicated.
Therefore, avoid simplistic statements such as:
"Fitzgerald believes..."
unless the wider text strongly supports the claim.
A safer analytical formulation is:
"Fitzgerald presents..."
or
"The novel associates..."
Ethnicity and Meyer Wolfsheim
Meyer Wolfsheim is one of the novel's most important examples of ethnic stereotyping.
He is presented as Jewish and associated with organised crime.
His physical description and manner are also shaped through exaggerated ethnic markers.
For a modern reader, this representation can draw upon anti-Semitic stereotypes that historically associated Jewish identity with:
criminality
financial manipulation
foreignness
social suspicion
This representation requires critical attention.
Wolfsheim and Criminality
Wolfsheim has an important narrative function because his association with Gatsby helps reveal the questionable origins of Gatsby's wealth.
However, Fitzgerald chooses to connect this criminal world with a Jewish character presented through recognisable ethnic stereotypes.
That choice has interpretative consequences.
A strong response should distinguish between:
Wolfsheim as an individual fictional criminal
and
the broader stereotype created when criminality is linked to exaggerated ethnic difference.
Avoiding an Oversimplified Reading of Wolfsheim
Do not claim that the novel argues all Jewish people are criminal.
The novel does not make such a direct statement.
However, it is appropriate to note that Wolfsheim's representation draws upon stereotypes that were culturally available within the period.
The issue lies in the pattern of representation.
Wolfsheim's Jewishness is marked heavily at the same time that he is connected with corruption and organised crime.
A modern critical reading should recognise the potential anti-Semitic implications of that combination.
Wolfsheim as an Outsider
Wolfsheim also fits the novel's broader interest in insiders and outsiders.
He has access to money and influence but does not belong to the established Anglo-American elite represented by Tom Buchanan.
This creates another parallel with Gatsby.
Both move within wealthy worlds while remaining distinct from old-money respectability.
However, ethnicity makes Wolfsheim's outsider status different from Gatsby's.
The comparison can help reveal that American society contains multiple systems of inclusion and exclusion.
Ethnicity, Class and Respectability
The novel's social hierarchy is not based upon money alone.
Characters are also judged according to:
family background
ancestry
ethnicity
behaviour
reputation
social connections
Wolfsheim's presence helps reinforce the idea that wealth does not automatically create social respectability.
The same broader principle affects Gatsby, though in a different way.
Fitzgerald's world is therefore stratified through more than a simple rich-versus-poor division.
Immigration and "Foreignness"
Ethnic prejudice frequently operates by treating certain people as permanently foreign, even when they participate fully in American society.
This matters to a novel concerned with identity.
The United States is a nation shaped extensively by immigration, yet some definitions of "American" have historically excluded people on racial, ethnic or religious grounds.
Tom's worldview depends upon an exclusive version of national identity.
The idea that some people naturally belong while others remain outsiders supports the hierarchies he wants to preserve.
Prejudice and Gatsby
Gatsby himself is primarily excluded through class rather than race.
Nevertheless, his treatment by Tom can be compared cautiously with other forms of prejudice because Tom judges people according to inherited categories.
Gatsby cannot completely control:
his family origins
the social class into which he was born
how established elites classify him
This does not mean class prejudice and racism are identical.
They are not.
However, both demonstrate the novel's wider interest in social boundaries and the power to decide who belongs.
Prejudice as Boundary-Making
Prejudice often works by dividing people into "us" and "them".
Tom repeatedly thinks in these terms.
He distinguishes:
established elites from social newcomers
men from women in terms of acceptable freedom
white people from racial groups he considers threatening
people who belong from people who supposedly do not
His worldview depends upon boundaries.
This makes prejudice central to the novel's broader treatment of hierarchy.
Race, Gender and Class Together
Tom's attitudes towards race should not be studied in isolation from his attitudes towards women and class.
In each case, he assumes that some groups should possess more power than others.
Hierarchy | Tom's position |
Class | Member of inherited wealthy elite |
Gender | Wealthy man in a male-dominated social structure |
Race | White man anxious about maintaining white dominance |
Wealth | Extremely financially secure |
Social status | Established and highly protected |
Tom benefits simultaneously from several hierarchies.
This helps explain why social change can appear threatening to him.
Prejudice and Masculinity
Tom's racism also contributes to his performance of masculinity.
He positions himself as someone capable of recognising and defending supposed threats to society.
His aggressive certainty allows him to perform the role of protector.
Yet what he is actually protecting is a hierarchy that benefits him.
This turns apparently defensive language into another form of dominance.
Racial Anxiety as Insecurity
Although Tom appears powerful, his racial anxiety can reveal insecurity.
A person completely confident that their dominance was permanent would have less reason to fear change.
Tom's alarm suggests he believes the social order could shift.
His prejudice is therefore partly reactive.
He sees demographic and cultural change not as neutral developments but as threats to his own identity.
Changing America and the Old Elite
The novel repeatedly contrasts an older social establishment with newer forms of American life.
Gatsby represents newly acquired wealth.
Jordan reflects aspects of changing female independence.
The modern city contains diverse populations and rapid movement.
Consumer culture produces new displays of prosperity.
Tom responds to these changes defensively.
Race is therefore part of the same wider pattern explored in Fitzgerald's representation of the Jazz Age [Fitzgerald and the Jazz Age].
The Harlem Renaissance Context
The 1920s also saw extraordinary Black artistic and cultural development, particularly associated with Harlem in New York.
This broader context matters because The Great Gatsby is set close to a city experiencing major cultural transformation.
Yet the novel gives very little attention to Black cultural voices themselves.
A modern reader may therefore notice a striking contrast:
the novel is fascinated by the novelty and modernity of New York, but largely excludes Black perspectives from its central narrative.
This absence can itself become relevant to interpretation.
Representation and Absence
Literary analysis concerns not only what a novel includes but sometimes what it leaves marginal.
The Great Gatsby claims broad significance for American dreams, identity and social change.
Yet its main characters come from a relatively narrow social world.
This raises useful questions:
Whose version of America is being represented?
Who receives narrative attention?
Who remains at the edge of the story?
How universal are the experiences the novel presents as American?
These questions can produce sophisticated responses without requiring unsupported claims about Fitzgerald's personal intentions.
Race and the American Dream
The American Dream appears to promise opportunity.
However, racial prejudice demonstrates that opportunity has not historically been distributed equally.
This creates a significant tension.
The ideal suggests:
anyone can succeed
while prejudice and exclusion establish:
some people are treated as more entitled to opportunity than others.
Tom's worldview exposes the contradiction particularly clearly.
He supports hierarchy rather than universal opportunity.
Gatsby and the Dream of Reinvention
Gatsby believes identity can be created.
Tom believes hierarchy should remain rooted in inherited categories.
Their conflict therefore reflects two different visions of America.
Gatsby's implied vision | Tom's implied vision |
Identity can be created | Identity is strongly inherited |
Social movement is possible | Existing hierarchy should remain |
The individual can transform | Established groups should retain power |
The future promises possibility | Change appears threatening |
Wealth can open doors | Birth still determines legitimacy |
Neither character represents a complete political philosophy, but the contrast is useful for interpretation.
Prejudice and Fear
Prejudice often appears in the novel alongside fear.
Tom's racial anxiety is explicitly about imagined loss.
He fears:
loss of dominance
loss of social certainty
weakening boundaries
social replacement
This suggests that prejudice can be sustained not only by hatred but also by insecurity.
Tom responds to change by asserting hierarchy more aggressively.
Prejudice and Power
Prejudice becomes especially consequential when held by powerful people.
Tom possesses enough wealth and social authority for his beliefs to operate alongside real power over others.
This connects prejudice with the novel's wider relationship between privilege and irresponsibility [Morality, Carelessness and Responsibility].
A powerless prejudice remains harmful.
A prejudice backed by social, financial or political power can shape the opportunities available to others.
Stereotype Versus Characterisation
A stereotype reduces an individual to assumed characteristics associated with a group.
Strong literary analysis should therefore ask whether minor ethnic or racial characters receive:
individual complexity
developed motives
interiority
distinctive voices
or whether they function mainly through recognisable group characteristics.
Wolfsheim is particularly important here because his Jewish identity is visibly marked and tied to criminality.
Black characters generally receive even less development.
Historically Offensive Language
Some of the language within The Great Gatsby is offensive by contemporary standards.
When discussing it in essays, there is rarely any need to reproduce racial slurs or insulting terms unless a very specific close-reading task makes a particular word essential.
Usually, you can write:
"racially offensive language"
"a racist description"
"a derogatory racial term"
"racialised language"
"an ethnic stereotype"
This allows precise analysis without unnecessarily repeating harmful language.
How to Analyse Offensive Language
If a passage contains historically offensive terminology, use a clear analytical process:
Identify the speaker or narrator.Establish whose language it is.
Explain the attitude represented.Is the language expressing fear, superiority, contempt or stereotyping?
Connect it to character or theme.For example, Tom's racism reinforces his obsession with hierarchy.
Place it in historical context.Connect it carefully with contemporary nativism and racial thinking where relevant.
Evaluate the text critically.Ask whether the novel exposes the prejudice, reproduces stereotypes, or does both in different places.
This is stronger than merely stating that the language is offensive.
Avoid Presentism
Presentism occurs when the past is judged only according to present-day assumptions without sufficient attention to historical context.
Avoiding presentism does not mean excusing racism.
Instead, historical understanding helps explain:
why particular ideas circulated
what anxieties they expressed
how prejudice operated
what contemporary readers may have recognised
You can condemn false racial hierarchies while still analysing why such beliefs were historically influential.
Avoid the Opposite Mistake
Historical context should never become an excuse.
Saying that prejudiced language was "normal for the time" is too simplistic.
Not everyone in the 1920s held identical views, and racial prejudice was contested as well as expressed.
A better formulation is:
The language reflects prejudices and racial assumptions circulating within the period, which a modern reader should analyse critically rather than treat as neutral.
Fitzgerald's Attitude to Tom's Racism
The novel gives strong reasons to distrust Tom.
He is presented as:
arrogant
aggressive
hypocritical
violent
entitled
Placing racist ideas within his dialogue therefore matters.
His racial claims form part of an established pattern of unpleasant attitudes.
This supports an interpretation that Fitzgerald uses Tom's racism to reveal his arrogance and insecurity.
However, that conclusion does not remove the problematic racial or ethnic stereotypes found elsewhere in the text.
A Critical Double Reading
A particularly strong interpretation is therefore a double reading:
First: Fitzgerald exposes the ugliness and insecurity of Tom's racist ideology.
Second: the novel itself still contains racial and ethnic representations that modern readers may identify as stereotyped or marginalising.
These positions are not contradictory.
A text can criticise one form of prejudice while remaining shaped by assumptions of its own historical culture.
Race and Nick's Narration
Nick's narration also needs critical attention.
He is not identical to Tom.
He does not share Tom's explicit racial ideology in the same form.
However, Nick's descriptions can still use racialised categories.
This reminds readers that prejudice can operate in different ways.
It may be:
explicit ideology
casual stereotyping
assumptions embedded in language
unequal narrative attention
Tom represents the most obvious form.
Other forms can be less direct.
Nick as a Product of His Social World
Nick is often treated as the moral observer of the novel.
However, he remains a character situated within his own historical and social environment.
His perspective is therefore not culturally neutral.
This is consistent with the wider need to question Nick's reliability and selective narration [Nick as First-Person Narrator].
A narrator can criticise some prejudices while remaining unaware of other assumptions.
Ethnicity and Criminality
Wolfsheim's representation is particularly important because it connects ethnic difference with crime.
The novel's criminal world also helps explain Gatsby's fortune.
This creates a troubling association between:
social outsiders
new wealth
criminality
ethnic difference
An essay can explore whether this reinforces the old-money assumption that outsiders are morally suspect.
The irony is that supposedly respectable old-money characters such as Tom and Daisy also behave destructively.
Respectability and Prejudice
Tom's social world treats itself as superior.
Yet Fitzgerald repeatedly undermines that claim.
Old-money respectability coexists with:
infidelity
violence
dishonesty
irresponsibility
prejudice
This creates one of the novel's central ironies.
The people most confident in their superiority often provide little evidence of moral superiority.
Prejudice and Moral Hypocrisy
Tom believes strongly in hierarchy.
However, his own conduct exposes the weakness of his claims to superiority.
His racism therefore contributes to the wider theme of moral hypocrisy.
He demands order while creating disorder.
He claims superiority while behaving irresponsibly.
He defends marriage while committing adultery.
He fears threats to civilisation while exercising violence.
This pattern makes prejudice part of Fitzgerald's larger critique of entitlement.
Race, Ethnicity and the Novel's Social Map
The novel's major settings also reveal patterns of inclusion and exclusion.
East Egg represents established privilege.
West Egg represents newer wealth.
The valley of ashes represents economic deprivation.
New York offers a more diverse and fluid environment.
Race and ethnicity add another dimension to this social map.
The modern city contains people and identities that the exclusive Eggs can keep largely outside their immediate social world.
This reinforces the symbolic importance of place and social geography [Setting and Place].
Is the Novel About Race?
Race is not as central to the plot as class, Gatsby's dream or his relationship with Daisy.
It would therefore be misleading to make racial conflict the novel's only or dominant concern.
However, race is still significant because it helps reveal:
Tom's character
anxieties about social change
ideas about American identity
the importance of hierarchy
the limits of the novel's own perspective
A strong essay keeps the theme proportionate while taking it seriously.
Race and Social Anxiety
Tom's racial fear belongs to a broader pattern of anxiety throughout the novel.
Characters fear losing:
partners
status
wealth
identity
control
Tom's racism turns this individual anxiety into a collective one.
He imagines established racial dominance itself under threat.
This enlarges his personal insecurity into a social ideology.
Ethnicity and Belonging
Wolfsheim's representation raises a related question about belonging.
Who is treated as fully part of the American social world?
A person may possess:
wealth
influence
business connections
and still be marked as socially different.
This parallels the novel's broader suggestion that economic success does not automatically erase inherited boundaries.
Prejudice and the Failure of Equal Opportunity
If some people are excluded according to race, ethnicity or ancestry, then equal opportunity cannot genuinely exist.
This makes prejudice relevant to Fitzgerald's wider examination of American aspiration.
Gatsby's experience exposes class barriers.
Tom's racial ideas expose another system of exclusion.
Wolfsheim's stereotyped representation draws attention, intentionally or not, to the way ethnicity affects social perception.
The result is a novel in which the ideal of open opportunity repeatedly collides with boundaries of belonging.
Changing Gender and Racial Roles
Tom's anxieties about race can also be considered alongside changing gender expectations.
He appears uncomfortable with a society in which established categories are becoming less secure.
Jordan's independence challenges older expectations of women.
Gatsby's rise challenges inherited class privilege.
Changing racial and immigrant populations challenge narrow definitions of American identity.
Tom responds by attempting to restore clear boundaries.
This makes him a character deeply invested in resistance to social change.
Is Tom's Racism Mainly About Fear?
Fear is certainly important, but it should not be used to minimise prejudice.
Tom's anxiety does not make his racism less serious.
Instead, fear helps explain its function.
Racist ideology provides Tom with a framework that tells him:
his superiority is natural
change is dangerous
hierarchy is necessary
people outside his group represent a threat
Prejudice therefore converts insecurity into a claim for continued dominance.
How Far Does Fitzgerald Challenge Prejudice?
There is evidence of challenge.
Tom's racist claims are associated with an unsympathetic character whose broader behaviour is repeatedly exposed as hypocritical.
The novel also presents a rapidly changing America that makes his desire for fixed hierarchy seem increasingly unstable.
However, there are limitations.
The novel:
gives little narrative depth to Black characters
relies upon racialised language
presents Wolfsheim through ethnic stereotypes
A balanced interpretation should recognise both.
A Strong Contextual Argument
Context should strengthen interpretation rather than become a separate history lesson.
For example:
Less effective:"Immigration was controversial in the 1920s."
Stronger:"Contemporary anxieties about immigration and changing American identity help explain why Tom interprets demographic change as a threat. His racial prejudice therefore reinforces his wider determination to preserve inherited hierarchy."
The second statement connects context directly to character and theme.
A Strong Argument About Tom
Tom's racism can be used to make a broader argument about his character.
He consistently interprets difference as threat.
Gatsby threatens class hierarchy.
Daisy's independence threatens gender authority.
Racial change threatens white dominance.
Tom responds to each threat through attempts to reassert control.
This makes prejudice central to understanding his worldview rather than an isolated unpleasant opinion.
A Strong Argument About America
Race and ethnicity also complicate the novel's treatment of national identity.
America can be imagined as:
open
self-inventing
mobile
future-focused
Yet the novel also contains:
inherited privilege
racial hierarchy
ethnic stereotypes
exclusion
anxiety about newcomers
The resulting tension is fundamental.
The promise of reinvention exists alongside powerful efforts to decide who is entitled to reinvent themselves.
Building an Argument About Race, Ethnicity and Prejudice
A strong essay should remain focused on the text while integrating context carefully.
One possible argument might develop like this:
Begin with Tom's racism. His racial anxieties reveal a wider obsession with maintaining inherited hierarchy.
Introduce historical context. Nativism and debates about immigration and American identity help explain why racial change could be represented as threatening.
Connect race with other hierarchies. Tom's racism parallels his attitudes towards class, gender and social mobility.
Analyse representation. The novel does not only depict prejudice through Tom, it also contains racialised and ethnic stereotypes of its own.
Consider Wolfsheim. His Jewish identity and criminal associations require critical analysis of ethnic stereotyping.
Examine absence and marginalisation. Black Americans receive very little developed narrative attention despite the novel's broader claims about America.
Reach a nuanced judgement. Fitzgerald exposes some forms of prejudice while the novel remains shaped by assumptions and stereotypes from its historical context.
A Strong Overall Interpretation
Race, ethnicity and prejudice in The Great Gatsby reveal a society anxious about who possesses power and who is allowed to belong.
Tom's racism is one expression of a much wider worldview. He believes strongly in hierarchy and reacts aggressively whenever established boundaries appear threatened. His fears concerning race therefore connect directly with his resistance to social mobility, female independence and challenges to old-money privilege.
The historical context of the 1920s helps illuminate these anxieties. Debates about immigration, national identity and racial hierarchy made questions of belonging especially visible, while modern urban life challenged narrow definitions of who could participate in American prosperity.
At the same time, the novel itself should not be treated as entirely outside these prejudices. Fitzgerald associates Tom's explicit racism with arrogance and insecurity, but the text also contains racialised language, marginalises Black perspectives and presents Meyer Wolfsheim through stereotypes connected with Jewish identity.
A sophisticated reading therefore avoids two extremes.
It is too simple to assume that every prejudiced statement expresses Fitzgerald's own beliefs.
It is equally too simple to assume that because Tom's racism is presented negatively, the entire novel is free from prejudice.
Instead, The Great Gatsby both exposes anxieties about racial and social change and reflects some of the stereotypes circulating within the culture from which it emerged.
Key Words 🔑
Key word | Student-friendly definition | How it may be used in an exam |
Nativism | The belief that established native-born inhabitants should be protected against immigrants or groups regarded as newcomers. | Use it to contextualise anxieties about immigration, national identity and social change in the 1920s. |
Pseudo-scientific racism | False theories that attempted to present racial hierarchies as scientifically proven. | Apply it to the ideas Tom uses to justify his belief in white racial superiority. |
Stereotype | An oversimplified assumption that assigns supposedly shared characteristics to all members of a group. | Use it when analysing racialised descriptions or the presentation of Meyer Wolfsheim. |
Prejudice | A negative or unfair judgement about people based upon assumptions about the group to which they belong. | Apply it to Tom's racial attitudes and wider questions of exclusion and hierarchy. |
Anti-Semitism | Prejudice, hostility or discrimination directed towards Jewish people. | Use carefully when evaluating the stereotypes involved in Fitzgerald's presentation of Wolfsheim. |
Common Mistakes ⚠️
Mistake: Assuming Tom's racism automatically represents Fitzgerald's personal beliefs
Why this is incorrect:Tom is a fictional character whose racism forms part of a broader pattern of arrogance, entitlement and insecurity.
How to improve:Distinguish between character, narrator and author, and analyse how Tom's beliefs function within his characterisation.
Mistake: Claiming Fitzgerald simply condemns racism throughout the novel
Why this is incorrect:Although Tom's explicit racial ideology is presented through an unsympathetic character, the novel also contains racialised descriptions and ethnic stereotypes.
How to improve:Use a balanced argument that recognises both the novel's criticism of Tom and the limitations of some of its own representations.
Mistake: Reproducing offensive language unnecessarily
Why this is incorrect:Repeating racial slurs rarely improves literary analysis and can distract from the argument.
How to improve:Refer to racially offensive language, derogatory terminology or racialised description, unless close analysis of a particular word is essential.
Mistake: Saying prejudiced attitudes were simply "normal in the 1920s"
Why this is incorrect:This treats a diverse historical society as though everyone shared the same beliefs and can accidentally excuse prejudice.
How to improve:Explain that racist and nativist ideas circulated and possessed significant influence, while remembering that such ideas were also challenged and contested.
Mistake: Treating race and class as identical
Why this is incorrect:Gatsby's exclusion as new money is different from racial discrimination. Different forms of prejudice have different histories and consequences.
How to improve:Compare systems of exclusion cautiously. Focus on the shared importance of boundary-making and hierarchy without pretending the experiences are equivalent.
Mistake: Ignoring Meyer Wolfsheim
Why this is incorrect:Wolfsheim is important to Fitzgerald's presentation of ethnicity because Jewish identity is marked alongside stereotypes of criminality and foreignness.
How to improve:Analyse both his function in revealing Gatsby's criminal connections and the problematic ethnic stereotypes used in his characterisation.
Mistake: Treating Black characters as major voices within the novel
Why this is incorrect:Black characters receive little developed narrative attention or interiority.
How to improve:Acknowledge their limited representation and consider what this marginalisation reveals about the social perspective from which the novel constructs America.
Mistake: Adding historical context without connecting it to the text
Why this is incorrect:Context becomes ineffective when it turns into detached historical information.
How to improve:Link context directly to interpretation, for example by explaining how contemporary racial and immigration anxieties illuminate Tom's fear of losing inherited social dominance.

Comments